Estimating Variability in Hospital Charges: The Case of Cesarean Section

Anna Perfilyeva,Vittal Raghavendra Miskin,Ryan Aven,Craig Drohan,Huthaifa I. Ashqar

2024-11-13

Abstract:This study sought to better understand the causes of price disparity in cesarean sections, using newly released hospital data. Beginning January 1, 2021, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) requires hospitals functioning in the United States to publish online pricing information for items and services these hospitals provide in a machine-readable format and a consumer friendly shoppable format. Initial analyses of these data have shown that the price for a given procedure can differ in a hospital and across hospitals. The cesarean section (C-section) is one of the most common inpatient procedures performed across all hospitals in the United States as of 2018. This preliminary study found that for C-section procedures, pricing varied from as little as \$162 to as high as \$115,483 for a single procedure. Overall, indicators for quality and whether or not the hospital was a teaching hospital were found to be significantly significant, while variables including median income and the gini coefficient for wealth inequality were not shown to be statistically significant.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand and explain the price differences of cesarean section (Cesarean Section, C - section) among different hospitals and the reasons behind them. Specifically, the author uses the newly released hospital transparency data to analyze which factors may lead to these price differences and explores the impact of these factors on price changes.

### Research Background

Since January 1, 2021, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in the United States has required hospitals to publish online the price information of the items and services they provide. This policy aims to increase the transparency of medical costs, enabling consumers to better compare the prices of different hospitals and thus make more informed medical decisions. However, preliminary analysis shows that even within the same hospital or among different hospitals, the price of the same operation may vary significantly. For example, the price of cesarean section ranges from a minimum of $162 to a maximum of $115,483.

### Research Objectives

The main objective of this study is to identify the key factors affecting the price differences of cesarean section by analyzing hospital transparency data. Specifically, the researchers hope to achieve this objective in the following ways:

1. **Data Collection**: Obtain price information of cesarean section from 108 hospitals and combine it with other socio - economic data (such as median income, Gini coefficient, etc.).
2. **Variable Selection**: Select multiple variables that may affect price differences, including hospital size, hospital quality, whether it is a teaching hospital, urban - rural differences, regional Gini coefficient and median income, etc.
3. **Statistical Analysis**: Use a linear regression model to analyze the relationship between these variables and price differences and determine which factors have a significant impact on price differences.

### Main Findings

After analysis, the researchers found that:

- **Hospital Quality** and **Whether it is a Teaching Hospital** are two significant factors affecting price differences. High - quality hospitals (such as those listed on the U.S. News Honor Roll) and teaching hospitals have greater price differences. Specifically, the price difference in teaching hospitals increases by an average of about $7,000, and the price difference in high - quality hospitals increases by an average of about $16,000.
- **Other Variables** such as median income and Gini coefficient do not show a significant impact.

### Conclusions and Prospects

Although the study has found some significant influencing factors, the explanatory power of the model is still limited (the R - squared value is only 0.165), indicating that there are many other factors that have not been included in the analysis. Future research can further improve the research in this area by expanding the sample size, improving variable selection, and using more detailed payer - specific negotiated prices.

In general, this paper reveals the potential reasons behind the price differences of cesarean section by analyzing hospital transparency data and provides a basis for further research.