Comprehensive and Comparative Analysis between Transfer Learning and Custom Built VGG and CNN-SVM Models for Wildfire Detection

Aditya V. Jonnalagadda,Hashim A. Hashim,Andrew Harris
2024-11-13
Abstract:Contemporary Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) research places a significant emphasis on transfer learning, showcasing its transformative potential in enhancing model performance across diverse domains. This paper examines the efficiency and effectiveness of transfer learning in the context of wildfire detection. Three purpose-built models -- Visual Geometry Group (VGG)-7, VGG-10, and Convolutional Neural Network (CNN)-Support Vector Machine(SVM) CNN-SVM -- are rigorously compared with three pretrained models -- VGG-16, VGG-19, and Residual Neural Network (ResNet) ResNet101. We trained and evaluated these models using a dataset that captures the complexities of wildfires, incorporating variables such as varying lighting conditions, time of day, and diverse terrains. The objective is to discern how transfer learning performs against models trained from scratch in addressing the intricacies of the wildfire detection problem. By assessing the performance metrics, including accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score, a comprehensive understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of transfer learning in this specific domain is obtained. This study contributes valuable insights to the ongoing discourse, guiding future directions in AI and ML research. Keywords: Wildfire prediction, deep learning, machine learning fire, detection
Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the efficiency and effectiveness of transfer learning in wildfire detection and compare it with models built from scratch. Specifically, by comparing three custom - built models (VGG - 7, VGG - 10 and CNN - SVM) and three pre - trained models (VGG - 16, VGG - 19 and ResNet101), the author explored the following issues: 1. **How does transfer learning perform in wildfire detection?** - The author hopes to verify through experiments whether using pre - trained models for transfer learning can better capture the complexity of wildfires, including variables such as different lighting conditions, different times of the day, and diverse terrains. 2. **What are the performance differences between custom - built models and pre - trained models in wildfire detection?** - By comparing custom - built models (such as VGG - 7, VGG - 10 and CNN - SVM) and pre - trained models (such as VGG - 16, VGG - 19 and ResNet101), the author evaluates their performance metrics such as accuracy, precision, recall and F1 - score in the wildfire detection task. 3. **What are the advantages and disadvantages of transfer learning compared to training models from scratch?** - The author analyzes the advantages of transfer learning in terms of computational efficiency, data requirements and model generalization ability, and also explores its possible limitations. 4. **How to optimize the model to improve the performance of wildfire detection?** - By adjusting the model architecture, fine - tuning parameters, etc., the author explores how to maximize the use of the knowledge of pre - trained models, thereby improving the accuracy and reliability of wildfire detection. ### Formula Representation To present the research results more clearly, the paper uses some key formulas to describe the model performance: - **Accuracy**: \[ \text{Accuracy}=\frac{\text{True Positives}+\text{True Negatives}}{\text{Total Predictions}} \] - **Precision**: \[ \text{Precision}=\frac{\text{True Positives}}{\text{True Positives}+\text{False Positives}} \] - **Recall**: \[ \text{Recall}=\frac{\text{True Positives}}{\text{True Positives}+\text{False Negatives}} \] - **F1 - Score**: \[ \text{F1 Score}=2\times\frac{\text{Precision}\times\text{Recall}}{\text{Precision}+\text{Recall}} \] Through these formulas, the author can comprehensively evaluate the performance of different models in the wildfire detection task, providing valuable references for future research. ### Conclusion This research not only shows the potential of transfer learning in wildfire detection, but also reveals the unique advantages and limitations of custom - built models. Through detailed performance analysis, the author provides valuable insights for future AI and ML research, guiding researchers to choose the most suitable model development method for wildfire detection systems.