The labour and resource use requirements of a good life for all

Chris McElroy,Daniel W. O'Neill

2024-11-10

Abstract:We use multi-regional input-output analysis to calculate the paid labour, energy, emissions, and material use required to provide basic needs for all people. We calculate two different low-consumption scenarios, using the UK as a case study: (1) a "decent living" scenario, which includes only the bare necessities, and (2) a "good life" scenario, which is based on the minimum living standards demanded by UK residents. We compare the resulting footprints to the current footprint of the UK, and to the footprints of the US, China, India, and a global average. Labour footprints are disaggregated by sector, skill level, and region of origin. We find that both low-consumption scenarios would still require an unsustainable amount of labour and resources at the global scale. The decent living scenario would require a 26-hour working week, and on a per capita basis, 89 GJ of energy use, 5.9 tonnes of emissions, and 5.7 tonnes of used materials per year. The more socially sustainable good life scenario would require a 53-hour working week, 165 GJ of energy use, 9.9 tonnes of emissions, and 11.5 tonnes of used materials per capita. Both scenarios represent substantial reductions from the UK's current labour footprint of 68 hours per week, which the UK is only able to sustain by importing a substantial portion of its labour from other countries. We conclude that reducing consumption to the level of basic needs is not enough to achieve either social or environmental sustainability. Dramatic improvements in provisioning systems are also required.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to provide the labor and resource use requirements for a decent or good life for all people globally. Specifically, through multi - regional input - output analysis, the author calculated the amount of paid labor, energy, emissions, and material use required to provide basic needs in a low - consumption scenario, and compared these requirements with the actual footprints of current countries.

### Main research questions:
1. What are the paid labor requirements for providing a good life?
2. What are the energy, emission, and material footprints required for providing a good life?
3. How do these requirements compare with the existing footprints of different countries?

### Research background:
The current global supply system is neither sustainable nor efficient, resulting in billions of people lacking basic needs and exacerbating the environmental crisis. No country can reach a globally sustainable level of resource use to meet the basic needs of its residents. Therefore, reducing resource consumption must be compatible with meeting basic needs. It is not only about reducing consumption to the basic - needs level but also requires significant improvements to the supply system.

### Research methods:
The author constructed two low - consumption scenarios:
- **Decent - life scenario**: Based on the decent - life standard proposed by Rao and Min (2018), it only includes minimum needs.
- **Good - life scenario**: Based on the minimum income standard released by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, it covers a wider range of social needs.

These two scenarios assume that the global economic structure remains unchanged, focusing on evaluating the impact after reducing consumption. The research mainly focuses on the UK because it is the basis of the minimum income standard and provides room for reducing the labor footprint.

### Results:
- **Decent - life scenario**: It requires 26.4 hours of work per week, and per capita energy consumption is 89 GJ per year, with 5.9 tons of emissions and 5.7 tons of materials.
- **Good - life scenario**: It requires 52.8 hours of work per week, and per capita energy consumption is 165 GJ per year, with 9.9 tons of emissions and 11.5 tons of materials.

Although these scenarios significantly reduce the current labor footprint in the UK (from 67.9 hours per week to 26.4 hours and 52.8 hours), they still require a large amount of labor and resources, indicating that reducing consumption alone is not sufficient to achieve social and environmental sustainability.

### Conclusion:
In order to achieve social and environmental sustainability, it is not only necessary to reduce consumption to the basic - needs level but also requires fundamental improvements to the supply system.