Nicodemo Di Pasquale,Jesus Algaba,Pablo Montero de Hijes,Ignacio Sanchez-Burgos,Andres R. Tejedor,Stephen R. Yeandel,Felipe J. Blas,Ruslan L. Davidchack,Jorge R. Espinosa,Colin L. Freeman,John H. Harding,Brian B. Laird,Eduardo Sanz,Carlos Vega,Lorenzo Rovigatti
Abstract:The theory of interfacial properties in liquid-liquid or liquid-vapour systems is nearly 200 years old. The advent of computational tools has greatly advanced the field, mainly through the use of Molecular Dynamics simulations. Despite the successes and advances in the theory of interfacial phenomena for liquid-liquid systems, the study of solid-liquid interfaces remains a challenge both theoretically and experimentally. The main reason why the treatment of solid-liquid systems has fallen behind that of liquid-liquid systems is that there are complications that arise whenever an interface involving solid systems is considered involving both theory of the solid-liquid interface and the calculations using MD simulations. An example of the former is that, contrary to the liquid-liquid case, the interfacial properties of solids depend on the lattice orientation. The main complications in these calculations arise from the fact that for solids the ``mechanical route'' cannot be used. To overcome this problem, several numerical approaches were proposed. The main purpose of this review is to provide an overview of these different methodologies and to discuss their strengths and weaknesses. We classify these methodologies into two main groups: direct and indirect methods. Direct methods are those that can calculate directly the properties of interfaces, while in indirect approaches the properties of the interface are not the primary result of the simulations. We also included a discussion on the origin of the difficulties in considering solid interfaces from a thermodynamic point of view. In the second part of the review, we discuss two key related topics: nucleation theory and curved interfaces. They both represent an important problem in the study of interfaces and in the context of solid-liquid ones for which the research is still extremely active.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the accurate calculation of the solid - liquid interfacial free energy (IFE). Although the theories of interfacial properties in liquid - liquid or liquid - gas systems are quite mature and these interfaces can be accurately studied by molecular dynamics simulations, the research on solid - liquid interfaces still faces many challenges both theoretically and experimentally. The main challenges include:
1. **Anisotropy of the solid - liquid interface**: Different from the liquid - liquid interface, the free energy of the solid - liquid interface depends on the orientation of the solid lattice. This means that for different crystal planes, even in the same solid - liquid system, the interfacial free energy will be different.
2. **Theoretical complexity**: Due to the existence of solids, the traditional "mechanical path" method (i.e., the method of determining interfacial properties by calculating the stress distribution in the sample) is no longer applicable. Therefore, new numerical methods need to be developed to overcome this problem.
3. **Experimental difficulties**: Experimentally, measuring the solid - liquid interfacial free energy is also very challenging. For example, when using the contact angle method, the measurement of the droplet angle will be affected by multiple factors, such as evaporation, adsorption, swelling, etc., which may lead to inaccuracies in the measurement results.
To solve these problems, the paper reviews different methods, including direct and indirect methods, for calculating the solid - liquid interfacial free energy. Direct methods can directly calculate the interfacial properties, while indirect methods infer the interfacial properties through other means. In addition, the paper also discusses the applications of the solid - liquid interface in nucleation theory and on curved interfaces, which are all hot issues in current research.