Exploring the Impact of Reflexivity Theory and Cognitive Social Structures on the Dynamics of Doctor-Patient Social System

Al Saqib Majumder

2024-11-09

Abstract:Conventional economic and socio-behavioural models assume perfect symmetric access to information and rational behaviour among interacting agents in a social system. However, real-world events and observations appear to contradict such assumptions, leading to the possibility of other, more complex interaction rules existing between such agents. We investigate this possibility by creating two different models for a doctor-patient system. One retains the established assumptions, while the other incorporates principles of reflexivity theory and cognitive social structures. In addition, we utilize a microbial genetic algorithm to optimize the behaviour of the physician and patient agents in both models. The differences in results for the two models suggest that social systems may not always exhibit the behaviour or even accomplish the purpose for which they were designed and that modelling the social and cognitive influences in a social system may capture various ways a social agent balances complementary and competing information signals in making choices.

Social and Information Networks,Neural and Evolutionary Computing,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the rationality of the assumptions in traditional economic and social behavior models that in social systems, interacting agents (such as doctors and patients) have complete information and rational behavior. However, events and observations in the real world are often in contradiction with these assumptions, indicating that the interaction rules among agents may be more complex. Therefore, the author explores this possibility by creating two different models: one retains the traditional assumptions, and the other introduces the principles of reflexivity theory and cognitive social structures.

Specifically, this research aims to answer the following questions:

1. **Does the dynamics of social systems always proceed according to the designed purpose?**
By comparing the results of the two models, the author hopes to understand whether social systems will exhibit behaviors that are inconsistent with their designed purposes. For example, under the classic rational - behavior assumption, the best doctors should get the most patients because of their ability and reputation; but after considering social relationships and cognitive influences, this relationship may change.

2. **How can we more accurately capture how social agents balance complementary and competitive information signals in the decision - making process?**
The research attempts to reveal how social agents make choices when facing complex information by introducing reflexivity theory and cognitive social structures. Reflexivity theory emphasizes the feedback loop between agents and the environment, while cognitive social structures focus on the impact of relationship dynamics in social networks on individual perception, decision - making, and action.

3. **Can we better understand the behavior of the doctor - patient social system through modeling?**
The author chooses the primary healthcare network as the research object, partly because there is a large amount of literature on doctor and patient choice behavior in this field. In addition, by optimizing the agent behavior of doctors and patients, the author hopes to provide a theoretical basis for improving medical services, thereby improving the quality and efficiency of medical services.

### Formula Summary

Some of the key formulas involved in this research include:

- **Calculation of Doctor's Treatment Effect**:
\[
E=\min(0.7,(C + E)\times(1 - TRC))
\]
where:
- \(C\) is the doctor's qualification score (low: 0.1, medium: 0.2, high: 0.3)
- \(E\) is the doctor's empathy score
- \(TRC\) is the technical resource constraint

- **Update of Patient's Health Level**:
\[
H=\max(0.1,\min(1,H + E\cdot(1 - R)))
\]
where:
- \(H\) is the patient's health level
- \(E\) is the treatment effect
- \(R\) is the patient's infection resistance

- **Conditions for Doctor's Qualification Upgrade**:
\[
\text{credential}=
\begin{cases}
\text{'medium'} & \text{if }r\geq0.5\text{ and }\text{exp}\geq50\text{ and credential = 'low'} \\
\text{'high'} & \text{if }r\geq0.8\text{ and }\text{exp}\geq80\text{ and credential = 'medium'} \\
\text{credential} & \text{otherwise}
\end{cases}
\]
where:
- \(r\) is the doctor's research ability
- \(\text{exp}\) is the doctor's experience

Through the application of these models and formulas, the author hopes to reveal more complex interaction mechanisms in social systems and provide new insights for improving medical services.