A Kalman Filter model for synchronization in musical ensembles

Hugo T. Carvalho,Min S. Li,Massimiliano di Luca,Alan M. Wing

2024-11-09

Abstract:The synchronization of motor responses to rhythmic auditory cues is a fundamental biological phenomenon observed across various species. While the importance of temporal alignment varies across different contexts, achieving precise temporal synchronization is a prominent goal in musical performances. Musicians often incorporate expressive timing variations, which require precise control over timing and synchronization, particularly in ensemble performance. This is crucial because both deliberate expressive nuances and accidental timing deviations can affect the overall timing of a performance. This discussion prompts the question of how musicians adjust their temporal dynamics to achieve synchronization within an ensemble. This paper introduces a novel feedback correction model based on the Kalman Filter, aimed at improving the understanding of interpersonal timing in ensemble music performances. The proposed model performs similarly to other linear correction models in the literature, with the advantage of low computational cost and good performance even in scenarios where the underlying tempo varies.

Audio and Speech Processing

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the issue of how musicians adjust their timing dynamics to achieve synchronization in musical ensembles. Specifically, the paper focuses on how musicians correct timing inconsistencies through feedback mechanisms during performance, particularly in the context of expressive timing variations and unexpected timing deviations that affect the overall performance quality.

To better understand the problem of interpersonal timing, the paper proposes a new feedback correction model based on the Kalman Filter. This model aims to improve timing accuracy in musical ensemble performances and has a low computational cost, performing well even under significant tempo variations.

### Main Research Questions:
1. **How do musicians achieve timing synchronization in ensembles**: The paper explores how musicians adjust their timing dynamics through feedback mechanisms during performance to achieve synchronization with others.
2. **Dynamic phase and period correction gains**: The paper proposes a new model that allows phase and period correction gains to vary over time, better describing the synchronization mechanisms among musicians under significant tempo variations.
3. **Effectiveness and applicability of the model**: The model's effectiveness and applicability in actual musical ensemble performances are validated through experiments, particularly under different performance styles.

### Research Background:
- **Biological phenomenon**: Timing synchronization in musical ensembles is a cross-species biological phenomenon, but its importance varies in different contexts. In musical performance, precise timing synchronization is a crucial goal.
- **Expressive and unexpected deviations**: Musicians introduce expressive timing variations during performance, which require precise control. Additionally, unexpected timing deviations can affect the overall performance quality.
- **Limitations of existing models**: Existing linear correction models have limitations in handling dynamically changing tempos and cannot adequately describe the synchronization mechanisms among musicians.

### Contributions of the Paper:
- **New model based on the Kalman Filter**: A feedback correction model based on the Kalman Filter is proposed, allowing phase and period correction gains to vary over time.
- **Low computational cost**: The model has a low computational cost, making it suitable for real-time applications.
- **Experimental validation**: The model's effectiveness and applicability under different performance styles are validated through experiments, especially under significant tempo variations.

In summary, this paper aims to better understand and address the issue of timing synchronization among musicians in musical ensembles by proposing a new model based on the Kalman Filter.