Abstract:Traditional medical training faces challenges like ethical concerns, safety risks, and high costs. VR technology offers a promising solution but is limited by low complexity and lack of tactile feedback. This paper presents a cost-effective haptic VR surgery simulation which simulates realistic Kidney Transplant using commercial devices to enhance training authenticity and immersion. Trainees can conduct incision and anastomosis procedures using a haptic stylus device that provides tactile sensations. Results from the test with medical participants showed that haptic feedback positively enhances the VR medical training experience.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address multiple challenges in traditional medical training, including ethical issues, safety risks, limited accessibility, and high costs. Although virtual reality (VR) technology offers a promising solution, existing VR simulations are deficient in complexity and haptic feedback, limiting their effectiveness.
Specifically, the goal of the paper is to develop a cost - effective and easily accessible haptic VR surgical simulation system, enhancing the realism and immersion of training by using commercial haptic and VR devices. This system is specifically designed for kidney transplant surgery to improve surgeons' skills and psychomotor performance, ultimately cultivating competent and confident surgeons, thereby improving patient survival rates and the quality of care.
### Main Problems and Solutions
1. **Challenges in Traditional Medical Training**:
- **Ethical Issues**: Actual operations may involve patient privacy and safety.
- **Safety Risks**: Novice doctors may make mistakes during actual operations, resulting in patient injury.
- **Limited Accessibility**: High - quality training resources are limited and difficult to meet all needs.
- **High Costs**: Traditional training methods are costly, especially when a real surgical environment is required.
2. **Limitations of Existing VR Technology**:
- **Low Complexity**: Existing VR simulations cannot fully replicate complex surgical tasks.
- **Lack of Haptic Feedback**: Existing VR simulations lack real - haptic feedback, affecting the realism and effectiveness of training.
### Solutions
The paper proposes a VR surgical simulation system based on haptic feedback, with the following main features:
- **Cost - effectiveness**: Using commercial haptic and VR devices reduces the initial setup cost.
- **Realism and Immersion**: Enhances the realism and immersion of training through haptic feedback.
- **Specific Surgical Simulation**: Kidney transplant surgery was selected as the simulation object because there is currently a lack of VR training for this surgery, and the demand for this surgery is increasing.
- **System Architecture**: Developed using the Unity game engine and OramaVR MAGES SDK, supporting multiple tools and applications, including plugins for haptic devices.
- **Haptic Feedback Model**: An extended spring - damping model was proposed to calculate the haptic feedback force, with the formula as follows:
\[
F = k(x - x_0)+bv + \mu N+F_{\text{pop}}
\]
where:
- \( k \) is the stiffness of the virtual organ, determining the elastic resistance based on the displacement \( x - x_0 \).
- \( b \) is the damping coefficient, representing the viscous resistance based on the velocity \( v \) of the interaction point.
- \( \mu \) is the friction coefficient, \( N \) is the normal force applied to the organ surface, and \( \mu N \) represents the frictional resistance.
- \( F_{\text{pop}} \) is the abrupt resistance when penetrating the tissue.
### Testing and Results
The paper verified the effectiveness and user experience of the system through four - stage testing:
1. **Familiarizing with the Equipment**: Participants got to know the equipment and the simulation system.
2. **Using Only VR Equipment**: Participants completed the entire simulation process.
3. **Using VR and Haptic Equipment**: Participants completed the same simulation process again.
4. **Collecting Feedback**: Collected participants' feedback through questionnaires.
The test results showed that participants generally believed that haptic feedback significantly enhanced their VR training experience and improved surgical skills and psychomotor performance.
### Conclusion
The conclusion of the paper indicates that integrating haptic technology into VR training can significantly improve the authenticity of the simulation, thereby better cultivating surgeons' skills and confidence. In addition, the system uses commercial devices, ensuring cost - effectiveness and being suitable for wide - scale promotion. However, the test sample size was small, and future research should increase the sample size and conduct longer - term and diverse medical procedure tests to further verify the effectiveness and robustness of the system.