Rotation curves of disk galaxies and General Relativity

Luca Ciotti

2024-11-06

Abstract:It has been proposed that the flat rotation curves observed at large radii in disk galaxies can be interpreted as an effect of General Relativity (GR) instead of the presence of dark matter (DM) halos in Newtonian gravity. In Ciotti (2022) the problem is rigorously explored in the special setting of the weak-field, low-velocity gravitomagnetic limit of GR. The rotation curves are obtained for purely baryonic disk models with realistic density profiles, and compared with the predictions of Newtonian gravity for the same disks, in absence of DM. The rotation curves are indistinguishable, with percentual GR corrections at all radii of the order of $\approx 10^{-6}$ or less, so that DM halos are required in gravitomagnetism as in Newtonian gravity. From a more general point of view, a list of the most urgent problems that must be addressed by any proposed GR-based alternative to the existence of DM, is given.

Astrophysics of Galaxies,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the flat characteristics of galactic rotation curves can be explained by General Relativity (GR), rather than by assuming the existence of Dark Matter (DM) halos. Specifically, the paper explores the rotation curves of pure baryonic disk models in the framework of General Relativity without dark matter and compares them with the rotation curves predicted by Newtonian gravitational theory. In his 2022 study, the author Luca Ciotti rigorously calculated these rotation curves, especially in the gravitomagnetic effects under the conditions of weak fields and low velocities.

### Main problem points:

1. **Can General Relativity explain the flatness of rotation curves?**
- The core problem of the research is to verify whether General Relativity can produce sufficient corrections under the conditions of low velocities and weak fields (i.e., the conditions in galactic disks) so that the rotation curves become flat, thus eliminating the need to introduce dark matter to explain the observed phenomena.

2. **The magnitude of General Relativity corrections**:
- The author calculated the correction term \( v_{\text{GR}}(R) \) of General Relativity to the rotation velocity and found that these corrections are very small, usually on the order of \( 10^{-6} \). This is far from sufficient to explain the observed flatness of rotation curves, which usually requires a \( 500\% \) correction.

3. **The consistency of different models**:
- The paper also discusses the behavior of different types of galactic disk models (such as thin disks, Kuzmin disks, Miyamoto - Nagai disks) under General Relativity. The results show that regardless of the model, the corrections of General Relativity are very small and cannot significantly change the shape of the rotation curves.

### Conclusion:

The main conclusion of the paper is that, within the current theoretical framework, the gravitomagnetic effects of General Relativity cannot explain the flatness of galactic rotation curves. Even after considering various different galactic disk models, the corrections of General Relativity are still very small, far from sufficient to replace the role of dark matter. Therefore, dark matter remains a necessary component in explaining the flatness of galactic rotation curves, whether from the perspective of Newtonian gravity or General Relativity.

### Formula presentation:

- **Rotation velocity under General Relativity**:
\[
v_{\text{GR}}(R) \sim v_{\text{N}}(R) + \epsilon v_1(R)
\]
where \( v_{\text{N}}(R) \) is the rotation velocity under Newtonian gravity, \( \epsilon=\frac{GM_{\text{disk}}}{R_{\text{disk}} c^2}\approx 10^{-6} \), and \( v_1(R) \) is the self - consistent gravitomagnetic correction term of General Relativity.

- **The magnitude of the correction term**:
\[
\epsilon\approx 10^{-6}
\]
This correction term is very small and cannot explain the observed flatness of rotation curves.

Through these analyses, the paper clearly points out that General Relativity, under the current understanding, cannot replace the role of dark matter in explaining galactic rotation curves.