Superradiant active optical atomic clocks: motivations and current challenges

Martina Matusko,Marion Delehaye

2024-11-06

Abstract:Current state-of-the-art frequency standards are passive optical atomic clocks where the frequency of an optical resonator is stabilized to a narrow atomic transition. Passive clocks have achieved unprecedented stabilities of 6.6 x 10--19 over one hour of averaging time [1]. However, they face intrinsic limitations, particularly due to thermal and mechanical fluctuations of the local oscillator. To surpass the limitations of the passive clocks and go beyond the state-of-the-art, the idea of building active optical atomic clocks emerges. These clocks would be optical counterparts of hydrogen masers, with the emitted frequency defined by the atomic transition and therefore inherently stable against cavity instabilities. This paper discusses the latest developments and future prospects in the field of active optical atomic clocks.

Atomic Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inherent limitations of current passive optical atomic clocks in terms of stability and accuracy. Although passive optical atomic clocks have achieved unprecedented stability (for example, reaching a stability of \(6.6\times 10^{-19}\) within an average time of one hour), they are still affected by the thermal and mechanical fluctuations of the local oscillator. In order to overcome these limitations and further improve the performance of time standards, researchers have proposed the concept of constructing active optical atomic clocks.

### Main problems:
1. **Limitations of passive optical atomic clocks**:
- **Stability**: The stability of passive optical atomic clocks is limited by quantum projection noise (Quantum Projection Noise, QPN) and the instability of the local oscillator. The formula for quantum projection noise is:
\[
\sigma_y(\tau)=\frac{1}{\text{SNR}}\frac{\Delta\nu}{\nu_0}\sqrt{\frac{T}{N\tau}}
\]
where SNR is the signal - to - noise ratio, \(\Delta\nu\) is the transition linewidth, \(\nu_0\) is the transition frequency, \(T\) is the interrogation time, \(N\) is the number of atoms, and \(\tau\) is the integration time.
- **Accuracy**: The accuracy of passive optical atomic clocks is affected by environmental factors (such as laser - induced electric fields, black - body radiation, magnetic fields, Doppler effects, etc.), which can cause systematic errors.

2. **Advantages of active optical atomic clocks**:
- **Superradiance phenomenon**: Active optical atomic clocks utilize the superradiance phenomenon, that is, when a large number of indistinguishable emitters are coupled to a single electromagnetic field, the constructive interference of possible decay paths from the fully excited state to the global ground state results in enhanced collective emission. The intensity of this emission is proportional to the square of the number of atoms \(N\), while the duration is reduced by \(N\) times.
- **Intracavity mode coupling**: Stable superradiant emission can be achieved by coupling atoms to a single mode of an optical cavity. Key parameters include the cavity linewidth \(\kappa\), the spontaneous emission rate \(\gamma\), and the single - atom Rabi frequency \(2g\). A superradiant pulse can be formed only when the collective vacuum Rabi frequency \(\Omega = 2g\sqrt{N}\) is much greater than \(\kappa\) and \(\gamma_\perp=\gamma/2 + 1/T_2\).
- **Low - frequency stability**: The linewidth of superradiant emission can be as low as \(C\gamma\), where \(C\) is the cooperation factor, defined as:
\[
C=\frac{(2g)^2}{\kappa\gamma}
\]
This low linewidth enables active optical atomic clocks to have extremely high frequency stability, reaching a fractional frequency instability on the order of \(10^{-18}\) within one second.

### Solutions:
1. **Optical - lattice superradiant lasers**: Continuous superradiant emission can be achieved by confining atoms in an optical lattice and operating under so - called "bad - cavity" conditions. This method has been verified in experiments and has shown very promising results.
2. **Atomic - beam superradiant lasers**: Continuous superradiant emission can be achieved by continuously guiding pre - excited atomic beams through an optical cavity. This method can avoid the problem of atom heating in the optical lattice, but still faces the challenge of high - flux atomic flow.
3. **Hybrid superradiant laser scheme**: Combining the advantages of optical - lattice lasers and atomic - beam lasers, the trapped atom ensemble is dynamically introduced into and removed from the optical cavity to achieve continuous superradiant emission.

### Conclusion:
Active optical atomic clocks overcome the inherent limitations of passive optical atomic clocks in terms of stability and accuracy by utilizing the superradiance phenomenon. Although some technical challenges still remain, the progress in this field provides new possibilities for future precision measurements and applications (such as deep - space navigation, gravitational - wave detection, etc.).