How the StarDICE photometric calibration of standard stars can improve cosmological constraints?

T. Souverin,J. Neveu,M. Betoule,S. Bongard,P. E. Blanc,J. Cohen Tanugi,S. Dagoret-Campagne,F. Feinstein,M. Ferrari,F. Hazenberg,C. Juramy,L. Le Guillou,A. Le Van Suu,M. Moniez,E. Nuss,B. Plez,N. Regnault,E. Sepulveda,K. Sommer

2024-11-06

Abstract:The number of type Ia supernova (SNe Ia) observations will grow significantly within the next decade, mainly thanks to the Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) undertaken by the Vera Rubin Observatory in Chile. With this improvement, statistical uncertainties will decrease, and flux calibration will become the main uncertainty for the characterization of dark energy. Currently, the astronomical flux scale is anchored on the numerical models of white dwarf atmospheres from the CALSPEC catalog, and every error on the model can induce a bias over cosmological parameters inference. The StarDICE experiment proposes a new calibration reference that only relies on observations from the optical watt defined by the NIST towards the magnitude of standard stars. It is currently operating at l'Observatoire de Haute-Provence and has been collecting data since the beginning of 2023. To overcome the photometric calibration uncertainty and reach a sub-percent precision, the instrument throughput has been calibrated with a Collimated Beam Projector. It will be monitored on-site with a LED-based artificial star source calibrated with NIST photodiodes. In this proceeding, we will first illustrate how an error in the photometric calibration can impact the SNe Ia distance moduli and thus bias the measurement of cosmological parameters. Then we will present the StarDICE experiment and how we can recalibrate the CALSPEC catalog at the millimagnitude level on the NIST scale with photometric analysis.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics,Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is **how to improve the measurement accuracy of cosmological parameters by improving the photometric calibration of standard stars**, especially the constraints on the properties of dark energy. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to reduce the impact of systematic errors brought by the current astronomical flux scale (such as the white dwarf atmosphere model in the CALSPEC catalog) on the distance modulus of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia), so as to avoid biases in cosmological parameters (such as the dark - energy equation - of - state parameter \( w \)).

### Background and Problems

1. **Growth of observational data**: In the next decade, with the implementation of projects such as the Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST) of the Vera Rubin Observatory, the number of observations of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) will increase significantly.
2. **Reduction of statistical uncertainty**: More observational data means that statistical uncertainty will be reduced, but at the same time, the systematic error of flux calibration will become the main source of uncertainty.
3. **Limitations of existing calibration methods**: The current astronomical flux scale depends on the numerical model of the white dwarf atmosphere in the CALSPEC catalog. Any model error will lead to biases in the inference of cosmological parameters.

### Goals of the StarDICE Experiment

To overcome these challenges, the StarDICE experiment proposes a new calibration reference method, which directly performs photometric calibration based on the optical watt standard defined by NIST. Specific goals include:

- **Reducing the uncertainty of photometric calibration**: By using high - precision laboratory standards (such as NIST - calibrated silicon photodiodes), achieve sub - percent - level photometric accuracy.
- **Recalibrating the CALSPEC catalog**: Using the data of the StarDICE experiment, recalibrate the CALSPEC standard stars with an accuracy of milli - magnitudes (mmag), thereby reducing the systematic errors caused by the differences between different versions of the CALSPEC catalog.
- **Improving the accuracy of dark - energy parameters**: Ensure that when measuring the dark - energy equation - of - state parameter \( w \), the accuracy reaches less than 3%, which meets the research needs of modern cosmology.

### Experimental Methods

The specific steps of the StarDICE experiment include:
1. **Laboratory standard transfer**: Starting from NIST's optical watt standard, gradually transfer to astronomical observation equipment.
2. **Instrument calibration**: Use calibrated photodiodes and artificial star sources to ensure the sensitivity and stability of the telescope.
3. **Standard star observation**: Regularly observe CALSPEC standard stars and analyze their photometric data to evaluate and improve the calibration accuracy.

Through these methods, the StarDICE experiment aims to provide a more reliable and accurate photometric calibration scheme, thereby providing a more solid foundation for future cosmological research.