Abstract:Bak, Tang, and Wiesenfeld introduced self-organized criticality with the example of a growing sandpile that reaches then sustains a critical density. They presented the abelian sandpile as a potential model. About a decade later, Dickman, Muñoz, Vespignani, and Zapperi claimed that self-organizing sandpile models share their critical densities with parametrized model versions that have conventional phase transitions. Fey, Levine, and Wilson subsequently demonstrated that this fails to occur with the abelian sandpile model. However, the primary subject of Dickman et al.'s work was stochastic sandpile models, and it was widely speculated that their paradigm might still hold in that setting. To this end, we confirm a conjecture of Levine and Silvestri by providing the first rigorous proof that activated random walk in dimension one is driven directly to a critical density corresponding to a parametrized phase transition and then remains there.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve a key problem in the theory of self - organized criticality (SOC), that is, to verify whether the activated random walk (ARW) model can directly drive the system to reach and maintain a critical density. Specifically, the authors aim to prove that in the one - dimensional case, the ARW model can indeed achieve this behavior, and this critical density is consistent with the critical density of the parameterized phase - transition model.
### Background and problems of the paper
1. **Concept of self - organized criticality**:
- Self - organized criticality was proposed by Bak, Tang and Wiesenfeld to explain the widespread power - law distribution and fractal structure phenomena in nature, such as earthquakes, avalanches, stock price fluctuations, etc.
- They hypothesized that the tension between energy accumulation and dispersion under many degrees of freedom would drive the system to spontaneously reach and maintain a critical state without the need for external parameter adjustment.
2. **Sandpile models and their variants**:
- The originally proposed Abelian Sandpile Model (ASM) is one of the classic models for studying SOC.
- Dickman et al. proposed the hypothesis that the self - organized sandpile model shares the same critical density as the parameterized model with a normal absorbing - state phase transition, but the ASM failed to verify this.
- The activated random walk (ARW), as a modified random sandpile model, is considered to be more likely to conform to universality and easier to analyze.
3. **Research objectives**:
- The main contribution of this paper is to first strictly prove that in the one - dimensional case, the ARW model can directly drive the system to reach and maintain a critical density, thereby verifying the "hockey - stick conjecture" proposed by Levine and Silvestri.
- This result not only provides the strongest theoretical support for Dickman et al.'s explanation of SOC, but also fills the gap in the lack of strict mathematical proof for Bak et al.'s original sandpile idea in nearly forty years.
### Mathematical formulation
Let \( \rho \) be the particle density, and \( \rho_{FE}(\lambda) \) be the critical density of the fixed - energy ARW model on the integer lattice \( \mathbb{Z} \), where \( \lambda \) is the sleep rate. Define \( D_\rho(n, \lambda) \) as the empirical density after adding \( \lceil \rho n \rceil \) particles on the interval \( [1, n] \) and then stabilizing, then:
\[
D_\rho(n, \lambda) \to \min(\rho, \rho_{FE}(\lambda))
\]
This holds in the sense of probability, that is:
\[
\lim_{n \to \infty} P\left( |D_\rho(n, \lambda) - \min(\rho, \rho_{FE}(\lambda))| > \epsilon \right) = 0
\]
This result shows that as the system grows, the empirical density of the ARW model will converge to the critical density \( \rho_{FE}(\lambda) \), and remain unchanged after reaching the critical density, which is exactly the behavior described by Bak et al.'s original sandpile idea.
Through the above - mentioned strict mathematical proof, this paper solves an important problem in the theory of self - organized criticality and provides a new perspective for understanding the critical behavior of complex systems.