Advancing DeFi Analytics: Efficiency Analysis with Decentralized Exchanges Comparison Service

Evgenii Onishchuk,Maksim Dubovitskii,Eduard Horch
2024-11-04
Abstract:This empirical study presents the Decentralized Exchanges Comparison Service (DECS), a novel tool developed by 1inch Analytics to assess exchange efficiency in decentralized finance. The DECS utilizes swap transaction monitoring and simulation techniques to provide unbiased comparisons of swap rates across various DEXes and aggregators. Analysis of almost 1.2 million transactions across multiple blockchain networks demonstrates that both 1inch Classic and 1inch Fusion consistently outperform competitors. These findings not only validate 1inch's superior rates but also provide valuable insights for continuous protocol optimization and underscore the critical role of data-driven decision-making in advancing DeFi infrastructure.
Trading and Market Microstructure
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the trading efficiency of different decentralized exchanges (DEXs) and aggregators in the decentralized finance (DeFi) field and provide a more accurate and unbiased comparison tool. Specifically, the paper introduces the Decentralized Exchanges Comparison Service (DECS), a new tool developed by 1inch Analytics, which aims to overcome the challenges faced by traditional data analysis methods in the DeFi environment. ### Background of the Paper and Problem Description #### Characteristics of the DeFi Ecosystem - **Dynamic Liquidity State**: Unlike traditional financial markets, liquidity pools in DeFi change frequently, resulting in unstable trading execution conditions. - **Invisibility of Private Market Makers (PMMs)**: The operations of PMMs are usually opaque and difficult to be included in the trading path calculation. - **Network Congestion and Gas Price Fluctuations**: High loads on blockchain networks can lead to transaction delays and increased costs. - **Complexity of Intent - based Trading Systems**: Intent - based trading systems (such as 1inch Fusion) adopt a declarative trading method, increasing the uncertainty of trading execution time. #### Limitations of Traditional Analysis Methods - **Dependence on Historical Data**: Traditional methods mainly rely on on - chain historical data and cannot capture real - time market dynamics. - **Lack of a Comprehensive Perspective**: Traditional methods fail to fully consider the impact of factors such as Gas price and network congestion on trading efficiency. ### Design Goals of DECS DECS aims to solve the above problems in the following ways: 1. **Real - time Transaction Monitoring**: Obtain the latest transaction data directly from the mempool or recently mined transactions to ensure that the analysis is based on the current market state. 2. **Application of Simulation Technology**: Use simulation technology to calculate the trading results of different exchanges, considering the same market conditions. 3. **Consideration of Comprehensive Factors**: Incorporate important factors such as Gas price and network congestion into the analysis to provide a more comprehensive evaluation of trading efficiency. ### Main Contributions 1. **Provide Real - time and Comprehensive Exchange Efficiency Evaluation**: Through real - time data and simulation technology, DECS can provide a more accurate exchange efficiency evaluation than traditional methods. 2. **Verify the Advantages of the 1inch Protocol**: Through the analysis of nearly 1.2 million transactions, DECS has proven the superior performance of 1inch Classic and 1inch Fusion on multiple blockchain networks. 3. **Promote the Optimization of DeFi Infrastructure**: The research results provide valuable insights for the continuous optimization of DeFi protocols, emphasizing the importance of data - driven decision - making. ### Conclusion By introducing the DECS tool, this paper solves the complexity and challenges of exchange efficiency evaluation in the DeFi field, providing users with a more accurate and fair comparison platform, thereby promoting the further development and optimization of the DeFi ecosystem.