The Case for an Industrial Policy Approach to AI Sector of Pakistan for Growth and Autonomy

Atif Hussain,Rana Rizwan

2024-11-08

Abstract:This paper argues for the strategic treatment of artificial intelligence as a key industry within broader industrial policy framework of Pakistan, underscoring the importance of aligning it with national goals such as economic resilience and preservation of autonomy. The paper starts with defining industrial policy as a set of targeted government interventions to shape specific sectors for strategic outcomes and argues for its application to AI in Pakistan due to its huge potential, the risks of unregulated adoption, and prevailing market inefficiencies. The paper conceptualizes AI as a layered ecosystem, comprising foundational infrastructure, core computing, development platforms, and service and product layers, supported by education, government policy, and research and development. The analysis highlights that AI sector of Pakistan is predominantly service oriented, with limited product innovation and dependence on foreign technologies, posing risks to economic independence, national security, and employment. To address these challenges, the paper recommends educational reforms, support for local AI product development, initiatives for indigenous cloud and hardware capabilities, and public-private collaborations on foundational models. Additionally, it advocates for public procurement policies and infrastructure incentives to foster local solutions and reduce reliance on foreign providers. This strategy aims to position Pakistan as a competitive, autonomous player in the global AI ecosystem.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore how to strategically treat artificial intelligence (AI) as a key industry in Pakistan's industrial policy framework in order to promote economic growth and maintain national autonomy. Specifically, the paper mainly addresses the following issues:

1. **Economic and Technological Autonomy**:
- Pakistan's AI industry is currently mainly concentrated in the service sector, lacking in product innovation and heavily dependent on foreign technologies. This dependence may threaten economic independence, national security and employment opportunities.
- The paper proposes to reduce dependence on foreign technologies and enhance the country's technological autonomy and economic resilience through educational reforms, support for the development of local AI products, promotion of the construction of local cloud - computing and hardware capabilities, and public - private partnerships.

2. **Market Efficiency and Risk Control**:
- The paper emphasizes the great potential of AI and the risks it brings, especially the market failure problems that may be caused by the unregulated adoption of AI.
- In order to maximize the advantages of AI and minimize its risks, the paper suggests that Pakistan should adopt a strategic industrial policy approach, including formulating public procurement policies and infrastructure incentives to promote the development of local solutions.

3. **Global Competitiveness**:
- The paper points out that AI can be an important tool for Pakistan to enhance its competitiveness in the global market. Through the development of AI, Pakistan can obtain significant benefits in terms of exports, attracting foreign direct investment (FDI), and increasing remittances.
- At the same time, the application of AI can also improve the productivity and competitiveness of various domestic industries, such as agriculture, medical care, manufacturing and education.

4. **Social and Economic Inequality**:
- AI - driven automation may lead to the loss of jobs in some labor - intensive industries, thereby exacerbating economic inequality.
- The paper calls on the government to take intervention measures to ensure that the introduction of AI will not lead to large - scale unemployment and create new job opportunities through skill development programs, especially in technical and non - technical fields.

5. **National Security**:
- Excessive dependence on foreign AI technology suppliers may bring national security risks, such as data leakage and external monitoring.
- The paper recommends establishing a safe and reliable AI ecosystem by developing local AI platforms and models, thereby protecting national security.

In short, the core objective of the paper is to incorporate AI into national strategic planning through formulating and implementing a comprehensive industrial policy to achieve economic prosperity, technological autonomy and social stability.