Abstract:Contrastive learning methods, such as CLIP, leverage naturally paired data-for example, images and their corresponding text captions-to learn general representations that transfer efficiently to downstream tasks. While such approaches are generally applied to two modalities, domains such as robotics, healthcare, and video need to support many types of data at once. We show that the pairwise application of CLIP fails to capture joint information between modalities, thereby limiting the quality of the learned representations. To address this issue, we present Symile, a simple contrastive learning approach that captures higher-order information between any number of modalities. Symile provides a flexible, architecture-agnostic objective for learning modality-specific representations. To develop Symile's objective, we derive a lower bound on total correlation, and show that Symile representations for any set of modalities form a sufficient statistic for predicting the remaining modalities. Symile outperforms pairwise CLIP, even with modalities missing in the data, on cross-modal classification and retrieval across several experiments including on an original multilingual dataset of 33M image, text and audio samples and a clinical dataset of chest X-rays, electrocardiograms, and laboratory measurements. All datasets and code used in this work are publicly available at <a class="link-external link-https" href="https://github.com/rajesh-lab/symile" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>.
Machine Learning,Artificial Intelligence,Computation and Language,Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in multimodal data processing, existing contrastive learning methods (such as CLIP) can only capture second - order information between modalities and cannot effectively capture higher - order information, which limits the quality of the learned representations. Specifically, when there are three or more modalities, methods such as CLIP handle these modalities by applying them in pairs, but this method cannot capture conditional dependencies, for example, the dependency between the first two modalities given the third modality. Therefore, the paper proposes Symile, a new contrastive learning method, which aims to capture high - order information between any number of modalities, thereby improving the performance of cross - modal classification and retrieval tasks.
### Background and Motivation of the Paper
1. **Background of Contrastive Learning**
- Contrastive learning methods, such as CLIP, use naturally paired data (for example, images and corresponding text descriptions) to learn general representations that can be efficiently transferred to downstream tasks.
- These methods usually achieve this by maximizing the mutual information between paired modalities, ensuring that the learned representations retain all correlations.
2. **Challenges of Multimodal Data**
- In many fields, such as robotics, healthcare, and video analysis, it is necessary to process multiple types of data simultaneously.
- Existing methods either design specialized architectures to handle all data types, which limits their generality and increases operational complexity; or apply two - modal contrastive objectives such as CLIP to pairwise combinations of available modalities, but this cannot capture higher - order conditional information.
### Specific Examples of the Problem
The paper illustrates the shortcomings of pairwise contrastive objectives through a simple ternary Boolean modality problem:
- Data generation process: \( a, b \sim \text{Bernoulli}(0.5) \), \( c = a \oplus b \).
- Using the pairwise contrastive objective of CLIP, even if the target \( b \) can be perfectly predicted from \( a \) and \( c \), the performance of CLIP is only equivalent to random guessing, with an accuracy of 0.5.
### Solution: Symile
1. **Total Correlation**
- Total Correlation (TC) is a high - order generalization of mutual information, defined as the Kullback - Leibler divergence between the joint distribution and the product of the marginal distributions:
\[
\text{TC}(x_1, \ldots, x_M) = D_{\text{KL}} \left( p(x_1, \ldots, x_M) \parallel p(x_1) \cdots p(x_M) \right)
\]
- Total Correlation captures the amount of information shared among a set of random variables, and a higher total correlation means more dependencies among the variables.
2. **Symile Objective**
- The objective of Symile is to maximize the total correlation, rather than just maximizing the mutual information between modality pairs as CLIP does.
- By deriving the lower bound of the multi - sample total correlation and using the Multilinear Inner Product (MIP) as a scoring function, Symile can capture high - order information between any number of modalities.
### Experimental Results
The paper verifies the effectiveness of Symile through multiple experiments, including cross - modal classification and retrieval tasks on a multilingual dataset containing 33 million image, text, and audio samples, and a clinical dataset containing chest X - rays, electrocardiograms, and laboratory measurement results. The experimental results show that Symile significantly outperforms pairwise CLIP in these tasks, even in the case of some missing modalities.
### Conclusion
Symile solves the limitations of existing contrastive learning methods in multimodal data processing by capturing higher - order information and improves the performance of cross - modal tasks. Unless there is prior knowledge indicating that the downstream task only depends on second - order statistical information, Symile should be preferred.