Abstract:We consider the linear causal representation learning setting where we observe a linear mixing of $d$ unknown latent factors, which follow a linear structural causal model. Recent work has shown that it is possible to recover the latent factors as well as the underlying structural causal model over them, up to permutation and scaling, provided that we have at least $d$ environments, each of which corresponds to perfect interventions on a single latent node (factor). After this powerful result, a key open problem faced by the community has been to relax these conditions: allow for coarser than perfect single-node interventions, and allow for fewer than $d$ of them, since the number of latent factors $d$ could be very large. In this work, we consider precisely such a setting, where we allow a smaller than $d$ number of environments, and also allow for very coarse interventions that can very coarsely \textit{change the entire causal graph over the latent factors}. On the flip side, we relax what we wish to extract to simply the \textit{list of nodes that have shifted between one or more environments}. We provide a surprising identifiability result that it is indeed possible, under some very mild standard assumptions, to identify the set of shifted nodes. Our identifiability proof moreover is a constructive one: we explicitly provide necessary and sufficient conditions for a node to be a shifted node, and show that we can check these conditions given observed data. Our algorithm lends itself very naturally to the sample setting where instead of just interventional distributions, we are provided datasets of samples from each of these distributions. We corroborate our results on both synthetic experiments as well as an interesting psychometric dataset. The code can be found at <a class="link-external link-https" href="https://github.com/TianyuCodings/iLCS" rel="external noopener nofollow">this https URL</a>.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Given the intervention distributions in multiple environments, how to identify the shifted nodes in the latent causal mechanism without recovering the complete Structural Causal Model (SCM) or the mixing function**. Specifically, the author focuses on the Linear Causal Representation Learning (CRL) setting, where the linear mixtures of unknown latent factors are observed, and these latent factors follow a linear Structural Causal Model.
### Problem Background
Traditional causal representation learning methods usually assume that perfect single - node interventions can be made on each latent variable, and the number of environments required is at least the same as the number of latent variables. However, in practical applications, it is very difficult to obtain such precise intervention data, especially when the number of latent variables is large. Therefore, a key challenge faced by the community is how to relax these conditions, allow for coarser - grained interventions (such as soft interventions, hard interventions, interventions on multiple nodes, etc.), and allow for fewer environments than the number of latent variables.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Identifiability**: The author proves that even under more general types of interventions, the latent factors that have shifted can still be identified.
2. **Algorithm**: An extensible algorithm is provided, which can infer these shifted latent factors from a limited sample in real - world scenarios.
3. **Experimental Verification**: The effectiveness of the method is verified through synthetic experiments and an interesting psychometric data set.
### Method Overview
The paper proposes a method based on Independent Component Analysis (ICA), which is achieved through the following steps:
- **ICA Decomposition**: Extract latent factors and their mixing matrices from the observed data.
- **Noise Ranking**: Rank the noise components through a test function to eliminate the permutation and sign uncertainties in the ICA results.
- **Shift Detection**: Detect which latent factors have changed by comparing the ranked matrix rows in different environments.
### Formula Representation
The key formulas involved in the paper include:
- Linear causal model of latent factors:
\[
Z = AZ+\Omega^{1/2}\epsilon
\]
where \(A\in\mathbb{R}^{d\times d}\) is a matrix encoding a Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG), \(\Omega\) is a diagonal matrix controlling the noise variance, and \(\epsilon\) is an independent noise vector with a mean of zero and a variance of one.
- Mixing model:
\[
X = GZ
\]
where \(G\in\mathbb{R}^{p\times d}\) is the unknown "mixing" matrix.
- Matrix representation after ICA decomposition:
\[
M^{(k)}=P^{(k)}D^{(k)}B^{(k)}H
\]
where \(P^{(k)}\) is a permutation matrix, \(D^{(k)}\) is a diagonal matrix, \(B^{(k)} = (\Omega^{(k)})^{-1/2}(I_d - A^{(k)})\), and \(H = G^\dagger\).
Through these formulas and methods, the author shows how to identify the shifted nodes in the latent causal mechanism under more relaxed conditions, thus providing new ideas and tools for causal representation learning.