Qidong Yang,Weicheng Zhu,Joseph Keslin,Laure Zanna,Tim G. J. Rudner,Carlos Fernandez-Granda
Abstract:Probabilistic prediction of sequences from images and other high-dimensional data is a key challenge, particularly in risk-sensitive applications. In these settings, it is often desirable to quantify the uncertainty associated with the prediction (instead of just determining the most likely sequence, as in language modeling). In this paper, we propose a Monte Carlo framework to estimate probabilities and confidence intervals associated with the distribution of a discrete sequence. Our framework uses a Monte Carlo simulator, implemented as an autoregressively trained neural network, to sample sequences conditioned on an image input. We then use these samples to estimate the probabilities and confidence intervals. Experiments on synthetic and real data show that the framework produces accurate discriminative predictions, but can suffer from miscalibration. In order to address this shortcoming, we propose a time-dependent regularization method, which is shown to produce calibrated predictions.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **When predicting sequences from high - dimensional input data (such as images), how to accurately estimate the probabilities and confidence intervals associated with these sequences and ensure the calibration of the predictions**. Specifically, the author focuses on the need to not only determine the most likely sequence but also quantify the uncertainty in the prediction when making sequence predictions in safety - critical areas (e.g., medical imaging, weather forecasting, etc.).
### Problem Background
In many practical applications, especially in safety - critical areas, it is not enough to simply predict the most likely sequence. We need to be able to quantify the uncertainty of the prediction, that is, provide probabilities or confidence intervals. For example, predicting changes in a patient's health condition in medical imaging or predicting future weather conditions in weather forecasting. The common feature of these problems is that, given an initial state (such as an image), a series of future states need to be predicted, and the evolution of these states may be uncertain.
### Main Contributions of the Paper
1. **Proposed a probability prediction method based on the Monte Carlo framework**: This framework uses an autoregressive model to generate sequence samples and estimates probabilities and confidence intervals through these samples.
2. **Discovered the time - dependent miscalibration problem of the autoregressive simulator**: The author found that autoregressive simulators trained with maximum - likelihood estimation are prone to miscalibration over time, that is, the predicted probabilities or confidence intervals cannot accurately reflect the real uncertainty.
3. **Developed a time - dependent regularization method**: To solve the above miscalibration problem, the author proposed a time - dependent regularization method, which can improve the calibration of the probability estimates in the prediction.
### Method Overview
- **Monte Carlo Estimation**: Generate multiple sequence samples through a neural network simulator, and then use these samples to estimate marginal probabilities, conditional probabilities, and confidence intervals for the time of event occurrence.
- **Autoregressive Simulation**: Use a convolutional neural network (CNN) to encode the input image and use a recurrent neural network (RNN) to iteratively estimate the conditional distribution at each position in the sequence.
- **Time - Dependent Regularization**: Apply an ℓ2 - norm penalty to the logits and adjust the regularization strength according to time to prevent the model from overfitting and improve the calibration of the prediction.
### Experimental Results
The author conducted experiments on multiple datasets, including synthetic datasets and real - world datasets (such as Atari games and FaceMed). The experimental results show that the method using time - dependent regularization significantly improves the calibration of the probability estimates in the prediction while maintaining high discriminative ability.
### Conclusion
The method proposed in this paper can provide more accurate probability estimates and confidence intervals when predicting sequences from high - dimensional input data and solves the miscalibration problem existing in existing methods. This provides a more reliable method for sequence prediction in safety - critical areas.
### Formulas Involved
- Marginal Probability Estimation:
\[
P(Y_i = a | X = x) = \frac{1}{M} \sum_{m = 1}^{M} 1\{\hat{y}_i^{(m)} = a\}
\]
- Conditional Probability Estimation:
\[
P(Y_i = a | Y_j = b, X = x) = \frac{\sum_{m = 1}^{M} 1\{\hat{y}_i^{(m)} = a, \hat{y}_j^{(m)} = b\}}{\sum_{m = 1}^{M} 1\{\hat{y}_j^{(m)} = b\}}
\]
- Confidence Interval Estimation:
\[
I_\alpha = [q_{(1 - \alpha)/2}, q_{(1 + \alpha)/2}]
\]
where \( q_{(1 - \alpha)/2} \) and \( q_{(1 + \alpha)/2} \) are the \((1 - \alpha)/2\) and \((1 + \alpha)/2\) percentiles after sorting respectively.
Through these methods, the author has successfully solved the problem of uncertainty quantification in high - dimensional data sequence prediction and improved the reliability of the prediction.