Why is it so hard to find a job now? Enter Ghost Jobs

Hunter Ng

2024-10-29

Abstract:This study investigates the emerging phenomenon of "ghost hiring" or "ghost jobs", where employers advertise job openings without intending to fill them. Using a novel dataset from Glassdoor and employing a LLM-BERT technique, I find that up to 21% of job ads may be ghost jobs, and this is particularly prevalent in specialized industries and in larger firms. The trend could be due to the low marginal cost of posting additional job ads and to maintain a pipeline of talents. After adjusting for yearly trends, I find that ghost jobs can explain the recent disconnect in the Beveridge Curve in the past fifteen years. The results show that policy-makers should be aware of such a practice as it causes significant job fatigue and distorts market signals.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the impact of the "Ghost Jobs" phenomenon on the labor market. Specifically:

1. **Definition and Identification**: The author first defines "Ghost Jobs", that is, the situation where employers post recruitment advertisements without the genuine intention to fill these positions. Then, by using the data set from Glassdoor and large - language - model (such as BERT) techniques, the author attempts to identify and quantify the prevalence of this phenomenon.

2. **Economic Impact**: The paper explores the negative impacts of "Ghost Jobs" on job seekers and the labor market. Specifically:
- **Costs for Job Seekers**: Job seekers will spend time and energy when applying for these non - existent positions, resulting in job - seeking fatigue and possibly prolonging the unemployment period.
- **Distortion of Market Signals**: The existence of a large number of "Ghost Jobs" may lead to the distortion of labor market signals, misleading policy - makers and job seekers.

3. **Industry and Enterprise Characteristics**: The author further studies which industries and enterprises are more likely to post "Ghost Jobs". Preliminary results show that large enterprises and high - skill industries are more inclined to post "Ghost Jobs".

4. **Explaining the Disconnection of the Beveridge Curve**: The paper also explores how the "Ghost Jobs" phenomenon can explain the instability and disconnection of the Beveridge curve (a curve reflecting the relationship between the job vacancy rate and the unemployment rate) in the past 15 years.

### Main Research Methods and Results

- **Data Sources**: The author uses the interview review data on Glassdoor, which is a platform allowing job seekers to anonymously share their interview experiences.
- **Models and Technologies**: Through natural language processing (NLP) techniques and the BERT model, the author classifies the interview reviews and identifies the reviews that may belong to "Ghost Jobs".
- **Main Findings**:
- **Prevalence**: The study finds that as high as 21% of job advertisements may be "Ghost Jobs".
- **Industry and Enterprise Characteristics**: Large enterprises and high - skill industries are more likely to post "Ghost Jobs".
- **Economic Impact**: Through the adjusted data, the author finds that the "Ghost Jobs" phenomenon can partly explain the disconnection of the Beveridge curve.

### Conclusions and Recommendations

The author believes that policy - makers should pay attention to the "Ghost Jobs" phenomenon, because it not only increases the burden on job seekers but also distorts the signals in the labor market. In addition, the author suggests that future research can further explore the causes and countermeasures of the "Ghost Jobs" phenomenon to reduce its negative impact on the labor market.