Abstract:This is the first of a series of three papers about the Elastic Manifold model. This classical model proposes a rich picture due to the competition between the inherent disorder and the smoothing effect of elasticity. In this paper, we prove a Parisi formula, i.e. we compute the asymptotic quenched free energy and show it is given by the solution to a certain variational problem.
This work comes after a long and distinguished line of work in the Physics literature, going back to the 1980's (including the foundational work by Daniel Fisher [29], Marc Mezard and Giorgio Parisi [50, 51], and more recently by Yan Fyodorov and Pierre Le Doussal [34, 35]. Even though the mathematical study of Spin Glasses has seen deep progress in the recent years, after the celebrated work by Michel Talagrand [67, 68], the Elastic Manifold model has been studied from a mathematical perspective, only recently and at zero temperature. The annealed topological complexity has been computed, by the first author with Paul Bourgade and Benjamin McKenna [15, 16]. Here we begin the study of this model at positive temperature by computing the quenched free energy.
We obtain our Parisi formula by first applying Laplace's method to reduce the question to a related new family of spherical Spin Glass models with an elastic interaction. The upper bound is then obtained through an interpolation argument initially developed by Francisco Guerra [42] for the study of Spin Glasses. The lower bound follows by adapting the cavity method along the lines explored by Wei-Kuo Chen [23] and the multi-species synchronization method of Dmitry Panchenko [55]. In our next papers [19, 20] we will analyze the consequences of this Parisi formula.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of calculating the quenched free energy of the Elastic Manifold Model at positive temperatures. Specifically, the authors aim to prove a Parisi formula, that is, to calculate the asymptotic quenched free energy of this model and show that it is given by the solution of a certain variational problem.
### Problem Background
The Elastic Manifold Model is a classical model that describes the competing effects between elastic self - interaction and disordered potential. This competition leads to rich physical phenomena, such as the behavior of random polymers and d - dimensional domain walls in high - dimensional random - field Ising models. This model was first proposed by Fisher and has been widely explored in subsequent research.
### Main Contributions
1. **Calculation of Asymptotic Quenched Free Energy**: By introducing a new spherical Spin Glass model and applying Laplace's method, the authors simplify the problem into a related variational problem.
2. **Proof of Upper and Lower Bounds**: To obtain the upper and lower bounds of the asymptotic quenched free energy, the authors use Guerra's interpolation argument to obtain the upper bound, and use the extended cavity method and the multi - species synchronization method to obtain the lower bound.
3. **Generalization to Spherical Models**: The authors also study a broader class of spherical models, which show more complex dependencies under the action of an external field, such as the pinning/depinning transition.
### Specific Formulas
The key formulas involved in the paper include:
- Model Hamiltonian:
\[
H(u)=\frac{1}{2}\int_{\Omega}\left(\mu\|u(x)\|^{2}-t(u(x), \Delta u(x))\right)dx+\int_{\Omega}V(x, u(x))dx
\]
where \(V(x, u(x))\) is the disordered potential, which follows a centered Gaussian process with covariance:
\[
E[V(x, u)V(x', u')]=\delta(x - x')B(\|u - u'\|^{2})
\]
- Variational formula for asymptotic quenched free energy:
\[
\lim_{N\rightarrow\infty}f_{N,\beta}=\sup_{q\in(0,\infty)^{\Omega}}\inf_{(\zeta,\Phi)\in Y(q)}P_{\beta,q}(\zeta,\Phi)
\]
where \(P_{\beta,q}(\zeta,\Phi)\) is a complex function, which involves the definitions of matrices \(K_{-t\Delta}\) and \(\Lambda_{-t\Delta}\).
### Conclusion
Through the above methods, the authors successfully calculate the asymptotic quenched free energy of the Elastic Manifold Model at positive temperatures and verify the predictions in previous physical literature. This result not only deepens the understanding of this model but also provides a theoretical basis for further research on the statistical mechanics of complex systems.