Identification of Z Cam's Historical Counterpart: The Quest for an Ancient Nova

Bo-Shun Yang,Susanne M Hoffmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1674-4527/ad89aa

2024-10-23

Abstract:In recent astronomical discussions, attempts have been made to link the known dwarf nova Z Cam to historical celestial events, particularly the "guest star" phenomenon reported in China in 77 BCE. Despite other suggestions and the problems with regard to the location of the event in 77 BCE, its identification with Z Cam is used in the Variable Star IndeX (VSX) of the AAVSO and in several research papers that aim to derive knowledge on the evolution of cataclysmic variables. Through the reconstruction of the super-constellation of the Purple Palace in the Han Dynasty, we found that Z Cam is actually located outside this enclosure, contradicting the records of the 77 BCE guest star being "within the Purple Palace". With newly found text versions of the guest star in 77 BCE, we narrowed down the position given therein. Combined with a new analysis of accompanying divination text leads to the conclusion that this guest star was actually a comet. Finally, through meticulous examination and comparison, we conclude that the guest star of 369 CE appears the most plausible candidate for Z Cam's historical counterpart, aligning with both textual evidence and modern astronomical observations.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to confirm the historical counterpart of Z Cam (a known dwarf nova), especially whether it is related to the "guest star" phenomenon in 77 BC. Specifically, by reconstructing the star maps of the Han Dynasty and analyzing historical documents, the paper explores the following issues:

1. **The relationship between the position of Z Cam and the Purple Forbidden Enclosure**:
- Early studies believed that Z Cam was located within the Purple Forbidden Enclosure, so it might be related to the guest star event in 77 BC. However, through the re - definition of the Purple Forbidden Enclosure in the Han Dynasty, the author found that Z Cam was actually outside the Purple Forbidden Enclosure.
- Using the "Cheonsang Yeolcha Bunyajido" (a star map from Korea) which can be traced back to the 7th century AD, the author reconstructed the Purple Forbidden Enclosure in the Han Dynasty and determined that Z Cam was not within its scope.

2. **The specific position of the guest star in 77 BC**:
- Through the re - interpretation of the original documents, the author found that there was a textual error in the description of "between the Pivot of the Dipper and the Pole". The character "Dipper" might be a misprint added later, and the correct description should be "between the Central Pivot and the Pole", that is, a certain position within the Purple Forbidden Enclosure.
- The author further explained the meanings of "Pivot" and "Pole", pointing out that these terms might refer to certain stars or celestial regions near the North Pole, rather than the Dubhe in Ursa Major.

3. **The nature of the guest star**:
- Through the analysis of other ancient documents, the author found that the guest star in 77 BC was more likely to be a comet rather than a nova or a supernova. This is inconsistent with the modern astronomical definitions of novae and supernovae.
- The paper also explored other possible historical records and finally concluded that the guest star in 369 AD was most likely the historical counterpart of Z Cam, because it was more consistent with the textual evidence and modern astronomical observations.

### Summary
The core problem of the paper is to verify whether Z Cam is related to the guest star event in 77 BC. Through detailed star map reconstruction and document analysis, it is concluded that Z Cam is more likely to be related to the guest star event in 369 AD. This research not only corrects previous misunderstandings but also provides a new perspective for understanding the historical evolution of Z Cam.