A gauge-invariant formulation of optical responses in superconductors

Sena Watanabe,Haruki Watanabe

2024-10-24

Abstract:Superconductors are often discussed in the mean-field approximation that breaks $U(1)$ symmetry. Since the $U(1)$ symmetry underlies the charge conservation, naive application of response theory sometimes gives results that are not gauge-invariant. We study the effect of vertex corrections on the electromagnetic responses of superconductors by employing the gauge-invariant formulation, called consistent fluctuations of order parameters, that manifestly satisfy the Ward identity. For inversion broken two-band superconductors, we find that the linear and second-order optical responses are significantly affected by vertex corrections and the conductivities near the gap energy almost completely disappear. We also investigate the linear optical responses in $d$-wave superconductors and obtained qualitatively different results compared to the result using the solution to the Bethe-Salpeter equation. The full photon vertex used in our study, manifestly satisfies the Ward identity. Our results demonstrate the fundamental importance of vertex corrections in exploring optical responses in superconductors.

Superconductivity,Statistical Mechanics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: in superconductors, how to correctly describe their electromagnetic response, especially the optical response, through gauge - invariant formulas. Specifically, the author focuses on:

1. **Gauge invariance problem**:
- In the study of superconductors, the commonly used mean - field approximation will break the U(1) symmetry, which leads to the failure of charge conservation. Therefore, the results calculated using the traditional response theory may not satisfy gauge invariance and violate the Ward identity.
- To ensure the physical meaning and mathematical consistency of the results, vertex corrections must be considered to restore gauge invariance.

2. **Quasiparticle excitation and collective modes in multi - band superconductors**:
- In multi - band superconductors with broken inversion symmetry, the linear and second - order optical responses are significantly affected by vertex corrections. In particular, near the gap energy, the linear optical conductivity almost completely disappears.
- It has been found that vertex corrections not only suppress quasiparticle excitation but also reveal the existence of collective modes.

3. **Optical response in d - wave superconductors**:
- For d - wave superconductors, the author compared the photon vertices calculated by two different methods (the Bethe - Salpeter equation and the method proposed in this paper) and found qualitative differences.
- The method proposed in this paper explicitly satisfies the Ward identity, thus more accurately describing the optical response of d - wave superconductors.

### Formula summary

- **BdG Hamiltonian**:
\[
\hat{H}_{MF}=\sum_k\hat{\psi}_k^\dagger H_{\text{BdG}}(k)\hat{\psi}_k
\]
where,
\[
H_{\text{BdG}}(k)=\begin{pmatrix}
H_N(k)&\Delta(k)\\
\Delta^\dagger(k)& - H_N(-k)^T
\end{pmatrix}
\]

- **Ward identity for one - photon vertex**:
\[
\Gamma_\nu(k,q)q^\nu=\tau_3G^{-1}(k)-G^{-1}(k + q)\tau_3
\]

- **Ward identity for two - photon vertex**:
\[
\Gamma_{\nu\lambda}(k,q,q')q'^\lambda=\Gamma_\nu(k + q',q)\tau_3-\tau_3\Gamma_\nu(k,q)
\]

- **Expression for optical conductivity**:
\[
\sigma^{\mu\nu}(i\Omega)=-\frac{1}{i(i\Omega)}\int dk\text{Tr}\left[\gamma^{\mu\nu}(k)G(k)+\gamma^\mu(k)G(k_0 + i\Omega,k)\Gamma^\nu(k,i\Omega)G(k)\right]
\]

### Conclusion

By introducing gauge - invariant formulas and considering vertex corrections, the author shows the importance of these corrections for the optical response of superconductors, especially their applications in multi - band superconductors and d - wave superconductors. This research emphasizes the necessity of maintaining gauge invariance when dealing with the optical response of superconductors.