Thermoelectric performance of a minimally nonlinear voltage probe and voltage-temperature probe heat engine with broken time-reversal symmetry

Jayasmita Behera,Salil Bedkihal,Bijay Kumar Agarwalla,Malay Bandyopadhyay
2024-10-24
Abstract:We investigate the thermoelectric performance of a voltage probe and voltage-temperature probe minimally nonlinear irreversible heat engine with broken time-reversal symmetry by considering extended Onsager relations, where a nonlinear power dissipation term ($-\gamma_h{J_L^N}^2$) is added to the heat current. The analytical expressions for efficiency at a given power and efficiency at maximum power, in terms of asymmetry parameters and generalized figures of merit, are derived and analyzed. Our analysis with broken time-reversal symmetry and nonlinear effect reveals two universal bounds on the efficiency at maximum power (EMP) that overshoot the Curzon-Ahlborn (CA) limit. Although the analytical expressions of the bounds on EMP look similar, their respective Carnot efficiency and the asymmetry parameter set the difference between these heat engines which can be proved numerically. We consider a triple-dot Aharonov-Bohm heat engine with a voltage probe and voltage-temperature probe for our numerical simulation experiment. Unlike the voltage probe, the voltage-temperature probe heat engine requires an anisotropy in the system in addition to the magnetic field to break the time-reversal symmetry. In both probe cases, we observe high efficiency with low output power when the tunneling strength $t$ is less than the coupling strength $\gamma$ and vice-versa for $t>\gamma$. Our numerical experiment demonstrates that the efficiency at maximum output power and efficiency at a given power can be enhanced by increasing the power dissipation strength ($\gamma_h$) although the output power remains unaffected. The added nonlinear term helps us to surpass the CA limit of the upper bound on efficiency at maximum power for both cases with and without time-reversal symmetry.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to optimize the thermoelectric performance of the minimum nonlinear irreversible heat engine with broken time - reversal symmetry and find the upper limit of the maximum output power efficiency. Specifically, the authors studied the efficiency performance of voltage - probe and voltage - temperature - probe heat engines in the case of introducing a nonlinear dissipation term. By extending the Onsager relations and considering nonlinear effects, they hope to reveal new bounds on efficiency in these systems and show how to go beyond the traditional Curzon - Ahlborn (CA) limit. ### Research Background and Problem Description 1. **Optimization of Thermoelectric Performance** - The need to improve the energy conversion efficiency of thermoelectric devices has driven research on optimizing thermoelectric performance. - Nanoscale heat engines perform heat - to - work conversion in a steady state and exhibit quantum interference effects, which provide a new way to improve thermoelectric performance. 2. **Broken Time - Reversal Symmetry** - Usually, the presence of a magnetic field will break the time - reversal symmetry of the system, thus affecting the thermoelectric response. - Introducing a third terminal (such as a voltage probe or a voltage - temperature probe) can introduce an asymmetric thermoelectric potential in a non - interacting system. 3. **Nonlinear Effects** - Based on linear irreversible thermodynamics, add a nonlinear dissipation term (such as \( -\gamma_h J_N^2 \)) to study its impact on thermoelectric performance. - This nonlinear model can reveal new efficiency upper limits and help to go beyond the traditional limit. ### Main Research Contents - **Theoretical Model** - Consider a three - terminal heat engine system, which is affected by an external magnetic field and is connected to three fermionic reservoirs (left, right, probe). - Explore the thermoelectric performance in the two cases of voltage - probe and voltage - temperature - probe. - **Nonlinear Effects** - Add the nonlinear dissipation term \( -\gamma_h J_N^2 \) to the linear Onsager relations and study its impact on efficiency and output power. - **Efficiency Analysis** - Derive the efficiency expressions at a given power and maximum power, and analyze their relationships with the asymmetry parameter and the generalized figure of merit. - Reveal two universal upper limits of the maximum - power efficiency, which exceed the traditional Curzon - Ahlborn limit. ### Numerical Simulation and Results - **Three - Quantum - Dot Aharonov - Bohm Heat Engine** - Through numerical simulation, verify the correctness and validity of the theoretical derivation. - Show the influence of different parameters (such as tunneling strength \( t \) and coupling strength \( \gamma \)) on efficiency and output power. ### Key Formulas 1. **Upper Limit of Maximum - Power Efficiency** - For the voltage - probe heat engine: \[ \eta^*_m(P_{\text{max}})=\frac{\eta_{C,m}(P_{\text{max}})x_m^2}{2(2x_m^2 - 3x_m + 2)-\alpha T_X T_L x_m^2} \] - For the voltage - temperature - probe heat engine: \[ \eta^*(P_{\text{max}})=\frac{\eta_C x^2}{2(2x^2 - 3x + 2)-\alpha T_X T_L x^2} \] 2. **Carnot Efficiency** - \(\eta_C = 1-\frac{T_c}{T_h}\) 3. **Relative Power Gain** - \(\Delta P=\frac{P - P_{\text{max}}}{P_{\text{max}}}\) ### Conclusion By introducing nonlinear effects and broken time - reversal symmetry, the authors have successfully found the universal upper limits of the maximum - power efficiency of the minimum nonlinear three - terminal heat engine and shown that these systems can go beyond the traditional Curzon - Ahlborn limit. This research provides a theoretical basis for designing more efficient nanoscale thermoelectric devices.