Random $2$-SAT: The set of atoms of the limiting empirical marginal distribution

Noela Müller,Ralph Neininger,Haodong Zhu
2024-10-23
Abstract:We show that the set of atoms of the limiting empirical marginal distribution in the random $2$-SAT model is $\mathbb Q \cap (0,1)$, for all clause-to-variable densities up to the satisfiability threshold. While for densities up to $1/2$, the measure is purely discrete, we additionally establish the existence of a nontrivial continuous part for any density in $(1/2, 1)$. Our proof is based on the construction of a random variable with the correct distribution as the the root marginal of a multi-type Galton-Watson tree, along with a subsequent analysis of the resulting almost sure recursion.
Probability,Combinatorics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the limiting behavior of marginal distributions in the random 2 - SAT model. Specifically, the authors focus on the set of atoms of the limiting empirical distribution of variable marginal distributions in the random 2 - SAT model under different clause - to - variable densities. The following is a specific description of the problem: ### Research Background Random constraint satisfaction problems are a research hotspot in the intersection of mathematics, physics, and computer science. Among them, the random k - SAT problem is a typical representative of such problems. As the simplest member, random 2 - SAT has achieved remarkable results in early research. For example, its satisfiability threshold was determined in 1992. However, for more complex random k - SAT problems (\( k \geq 3 \)), the existence and location of the satisfiability threshold have only been strictly proven recently. ### Specific Problems This paper mainly explores the properties of the limiting empirical distribution of variable marginal distributions in the random 2 - SAT model. Specifically, the authors focus on: - For all clause - to - variable densities not exceeding the satisfiability threshold, what is the set of atoms of the limiting empirical marginal distribution? - Under different density conditions, does this distribution have discrete and continuous parts? ### Main Contributions The main contributions of the paper are as follows: 1. **Determination of the Set of Atoms**: For all clause - to - variable densities \( d \in (0, 2) \), the pure - point support of the limiting empirical marginal distribution is the set of rational numbers \( \mathbb{Q} \cap (0, 1) \). 2. **Distinction between Discrete and Continuous Parts**: When \( d \in (0, 1] \), the distribution is discrete; when \( d \in (1, 2) \), the distribution has a non - trivial continuous part, and the support set of this continuous part is the entire interval [0, 1]. ### Methodology The authors prove the above conclusions by constructing a multi - type Galton - Watson tree and analyzing the asymptotic behavior of its root - node marginals. Specific steps include: - Construct a random variable \( \mu_o \) such that its distribution is equal to the limiting empirical marginal distribution \( \pi_d \). - Analyze the recursive properties of this random variable on the multi - type Galton - Watson tree. - Prove the distribution characteristics of this random variable by the method of almost sure convergence. ### Conclusion This research not only deepens the understanding of the random 2 - SAT model but also provides a new perspective for studying marginal structures in other random constraint satisfaction problems. In particular, it reveals the complexity of marginal distributions in the random 2 - SAT model and how these distributions are affected by local neighborhood fluctuations. Through these results, the authors hope to provide a theoretical basis for further understanding marginal structures in random constraint satisfaction problems and provide references for future research.