How host mobility patterns shape antigenic escape during viral-immune co-evolution

Natalie Blot,Caelan Brooks,Daniel W. Swartz,Eslam Abdelaleem,Martin Garic,Andrea Iglesias-Ramas,Michael Pasek,Thierry Mora,Aleksandra M. Walczak
2024-10-23
Abstract:Viruses like influenza have long coevolved with host immune systems, gradually shaping the evolutionary trajectory of these pathogens. Host immune systems develop immunity against circulating strains, which in turn avoid extinction by exploiting antigenic escape mutations that render new strains immune from existing antibodies in the host population. Infected hosts are also mobile, which can spread the virus to regions without developed host immunity, offering additional reservoirs for viral growth. While the effects of migration on long term stability have been investigated, we know little about how antigenic escape coupled with migration changes the survival and spread of emerging viruses. By considering the two processes on equal footing, we show that on short timescales an intermediate host mobility rate increases the survival probability of the virus through antigenic escape. We show that more strongly connected migratory networks decrease the survival probability of the virus. Using data from high traffic airports we argue that current human migration rates are beneficial for viral survival.
Populations and Evolution
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How do host migration patterns affect the survival and spread of viruses during antigenic escape?** Specifically, the author focuses on how, in the process of co - evolution between viruses and the host immune system, the mobility of the host (such as human migration through transportation hubs like airports) interacts with antigenic escape, thereby changing the survival probability and spread pattern of new virus strains. ### Background of the paper 1. **Co - evolution of viruses and the host immune system**: - Viruses (such as influenza viruses) co - evolve with the immune systems of their hosts over a long period. The host immune system will develop immunity against prevalent virus strains. - Viruses avoid being recognized by existing antibodies in the host through antigenic escape mutations, thus avoiding extinction. 2. **The impact of host migration**: - Infected hosts are mobile, which will cause the virus to spread to areas where immunity has not been established, providing additional resources for the growth of the virus. - Although previous studies have explored the effect of migration on long - term stability, there are few studies on how antigenic escape and migration jointly affect the survival and spread of new virus strains. ### Research questions - **Main question**: How does the host migration pattern increase the probability of virus survival through antigenic escape in the short term? - **Specific questions**: - How does the host migration rate affect the survival probability of the virus? - Does a stronger migration dynamic network reduce the survival probability of the virus? - What is the impact of the current human migration rate (such as data from high - traffic airports) on virus survival? ### Research methods The author studied the impact of host migration on the survival of new virus strains after an outbreak by constructing a stochastic model that combines epidemiological dynamics and antigenic drift. The model takes the following aspects into account: - **Antigen space**: All possible antigenic strains are described using a one - dimensional antigen space. - **Host migration**: Hosts can migrate between different demes. - **Immune response**: After being infected, the host will produce an adaptive immune response and clear the infection. ### Main findings - **Moderate migration rate maximizes the virus survival probability**: A moderate host migration rate can amplify the antigenic diversity of secondary outbreaks, thereby increasing the virus survival probability. - **A stronger migration dynamic network reduces the virus survival probability**: A more closely connected migration dynamic network will reduce the virus survival probability. - **The current human migration rate is favorable for virus survival**: Based on data from high - traffic airports, the current human migration rate is favorable for virus survival. Through these studies, the author has revealed the important impact of host migration patterns on virus survival during antigenic escape, providing a new perspective for understanding virus spread and control.