Recent consumer OLED monitors can be suitable for vision science

Tarek Abu Haila,Korbinian Kunst,Tran Quoc Khanh,Thomas S. A. Wallis

2024-10-22

Abstract:Vision science imposes rigorous requirements for the design and execution of psychophysical studies and experiments. These requirements ensure precise control over variables, accurate measurement of perceptual responses, and reproducibility of results, which are essential for investigating visual perception and its underlying mechanisms. Since different experiments have different requirements, not all aspects of a display system are critical for a given setting. Therefore, some display systems may be suitable for certain types of experiments but unsuitable for others. An additional challenge is that the performance of consumer systems is often highly dependent on specific monitor settings and firmware behavior. Here, we evaluate the performance of four display systems: a consumer LCD gaming monitor, a consumer OLED gaming monitor, a consumer OLED TV, and a VPixx PROPixx projector system. To allow the reader to assess the suitability of these systems for different experiments, we present a range of different metrics: luminance behavior, luminance uniformity across display surface, estimated gamma values and linearity, channel additivity, channel dependency, color gamut, pixel response time, and pixel waveform. In addition, we exhaustively report the monitor firmware settings used. Our analyses show that current consumer-level OLED display systems are promising, and adequate to fulfill the requirements of some critical vision science experiments, allowing laboratories to run their experiments even without investing in high-quality professional display systems. For example, the tested Asus OLED gaming monitor shows excellent response time, a sharp square waveform even at 240 Hz, a color gamut that covers 94% of DCI-P3 color space, and the best luminance uniformity among all four tested systems, making it a favorable option on price-to-performance ratio.

Graphics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate whether current consumer - level displays (especially OLED displays) can meet the strict requirements of visual science research. Specifically, the author evaluates the performance of these systems in the following aspects by testing four different display systems (including consumer - level LCD, OLED displays and projectors):

1. **Brightness behavior**: Measure the brightness response of each channel (R, G, B) and grayscale (R = G = B) at different bit depths.
2. **Brightness uniformity**: Ensure that the brightness output across the entire display surface is consistent.
3. **Estimation of gamma value and linearity**: Check whether the relationship between the brightness output and the pixel value conforms to the expected gamma function or linear relationship.
4. **Channel additivity**: Verify the independence of RGB channels and the consistency of their behavior when combined.
5. **Channel dependence**: Check whether a change in one channel will affect the brightness output of other channels.
6. **Color gamut**: Evaluate the range of colors that the display can present.
7. **Pixel response time**: Measure the time required for a pixel to switch from one state to another.
8. **Pixel waveform**: Analyze the signal waveform to ensure that it conforms to the expected time characteristics.
9. **Fill factor**: Investigate the effect of different proportions of activated pixels on the brightness output.

Through these evaluations, the author hopes to determine whether current consumer - level OLED displays can meet the needs of visual science research without relying on expensive professional display devices. For example, they found that the tested Asus OLED gaming monitor performed excellently, with excellent response time, nearly square waveforms (even at 240Hz), covering 94% of the DCI - P3 color gamut, and having the best brightness uniformity among all four tested systems, making it a highly cost - effective choice.

### Key Formulas

- **Pixel density calculation formula**:
\[
PPM=\frac{dp}{dl}=\frac{\sqrt{X^{2}+Y^{2}}}{\sqrt{W^{2}+H^{2}}}
\]
where \(PPM\) is the number of pixels per millimeter, \(dp\) is the number of diagonal pixels, \(dl\) is the diagonal length (in millimeters), \(X\) is the number of horizontal pixels, \(Y\) is the number of vertical pixels, \(W\) is the width (in millimeters), and \(H\) is the height (in millimeters).

- **Gamma function**:
\[
V_{\text{out}} = V_{\text{in}}^{\gamma}
\]
where \(V_{\text{out}}\) is the output brightness, \(V_{\text{in}}\) is the input brightness, and \(\gamma\) is the gamma value.

### Summary

This paper, through a detailed evaluation of four display systems, shows that current consumer - level OLED displays perform excellently in some key visual science experiments and can be an affordable alternative to professional display systems. This provides laboratories with more options to conduct high - quality visual science research without investing in expensive professional equipment.