Beyond Diffusion: A Causality-Preserving Model for Cosmic Ray Propagation

Norita Kawanaka,Rohta Takahashi
2024-10-19
Abstract:We propose a brand-new formalism for the propagation of relativistic cosmic ray (CR) particles. The propagation of CRs has often been described using the diffusion approximation, which has the drawback that the propagation speed of CRs near the source exceeds the speed of light. By applying the analytic solution of the time-dependent distribution function of photons propagating while undergoing scattering, which we recently proposed, we have succeeded in formulating the propagation of relativistic CRs while preserving causality. The obtained formulae give correct expressions both in the diffusion regime and ballistic regime, as well as the transition between them. They can be applied to the propagation of PeV CRs around their sources (PeVatrons), the propagation of ultra-high energy CRs, and the description of TeV gamma-ray halos around pulsars.
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that when describing the propagation of relativistic cosmic - ray (CR) particles, the traditional diffusion approximation method has the problem of superluminal propagation. Specifically, when considering the propagation of cosmic rays in a turbulent magnetic field, the diffusion approximation method is not applicable on short scales (less than the scattering mean free path \( \ell_0 \)), because at such scales, the propagation speed of particles will exceed the speed of light, which violates causality. Therefore, the paper proposes a new formalization method that can accurately describe the transition process from ballistic propagation to diffusive propagation while maintaining causality. ### Main problems 1. **Superluminal propagation problem**: The traditional diffusion approximation method, when describing the propagation of cosmic - ray particles on short scales, will cause the propagation speed of particles to exceed the speed of light, which violates the basic principles of relativity. 2. **Ballistic and diffusive transition**: A formalization method is required that can simultaneously describe ballistic propagation and diffusive propagation and can handle the transition between them. ### Solutions The paper proposes a new analytical method. By applying the analytical solution of the time - dependent distribution function of photons under multiple scatterings, it successfully describes the propagation process of relativistic cosmic - ray particles while retaining causality. This method is applicable not only to the diffusion region and the ballistic region but also can describe the transition between them. ### Application scenarios - **PeV - energy cosmic - ray sources (PeVatrons)**: Describe the propagation of PeV - energy cosmic rays near their sources. - **Ultra - high - energy cosmic rays (UHECRs)**: Describe the propagation of ultra - high - energy cosmic rays in the intergalactic space. - **TeV gamma - ray halos around pulsars**: Describe the TeV gamma - ray halos generated by the escape of cosmic - ray electrons/positrons around pulsar wind nebulae (PWNe). ### Method overview 1. **Diffusion equation review**: Briefly review the diffusion equation that describes the propagation of charged relativistic particles in a turbulent magnetic field. 2. **New method introduction**: Propose a new method to describe the propagation of cosmic - ray particles. This method is based on the definition of the particle number density flux \( N^\mu \) and obtains the particle distribution function through an analytical solution. 3. **Distribution function calculation**: Calculate in detail the particle distribution function at different time scales and compare and verify it with the results of Monte Carlo simulations. ### Conclusion The paper successfully proposes a new analytical method that can accurately describe the entire process of relativistic cosmic - ray particles from ballistic propagation to diffusive propagation while maintaining causality. This method is of great significance for understanding the propagation mechanism of high - energy cosmic rays.