Observing the Southern US Culture of Honor Using Large-Scale Social Media Analysis

Juho Kim,Michael Guerzhoy

2024-10-11

Abstract:A \textit{culture of honor} refers to a social system where individuals' status, reputation, and esteem play a central role in governing interpersonal relations. Past works have associated this concept with the United States (US) South and related with it various traits such as higher sensitivity to insult, a higher value on reputation, and a tendency to react violently to insults. In this paper, we hypothesize and confirm that internet users from the US South, where a \textit{culture of honor} is more prevalent, are more likely to display a trait predicted by their belonging to a \textit{culture of honor}. Specifically, we test the hypothesis that US Southerners are more likely to retaliate to personal attacks by personally attacking back. We leverage OpenAI's GPT-3.5 API to both geolocate internet users and to automatically detect whether users are insulting each other. We validate the use of GPT-3.5 by measuring its performance on manually-labeled subsets of the data. Our work demonstrates the potential of formulating a hypothesis based on a conceptual framework, operationalizing it in a way that is amenable to large-scale LLM-aided analysis, manually validating the use of the LLM, and drawing a conclusion.

Social and Information Networks,Computation and Language

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to verify whether the "culture of honor" in the American South causes Internet users to be more likely to fight back when personally attacked. Specifically, the author hypothesized and verified that Internet users from the American South (more prevalent in the culture of honor) are more likely to defend their name and reputation by fighting back when personally attacked than users from other regions.

### Research Background
The "culture of honor" refers to a social system in which an individual's status, reputation, and respect play a central role in interpersonal communication. This culture emphasizes the maintenance and defense of the honor of individuals and their families or groups, and responds to insults or challenges, ranging from verbal defense to physical retaliation. Previous research has associated this concept with the American South and has discovered some related characteristics, such as being more sensitive to insults, attaching more importance to reputation, and tending to respond to insults with violence.

### Research Hypothesis
The author hypothesized and verified the following hypothesis: Internet users in the American South are more likely to fight back when personally attacked. To verify this hypothesis, the study used OpenAI's GPT - 3.5 API to locate the geographical location of Internet users and automatically detect whether there is mutual insulting behavior between users.

### Methodology
1. **Data Acquisition**: Researchers obtained Internet user conversation data from the subreddit - changemyview dataset in ConvoKit.
2. **Model Fine - Tuning**: Researchers used the GPT - 3.5 model to geolocate users and mark personal attacking behaviors in conversations.
3. **Data Analysis**: Researchers compared the retaliation rates of southern and non - southern users when personally attacked and introduced three indicators: Aggression, Response, and Retaliation, to evaluate the behavioral differences of users in different regions.

### Main Conclusions
Through the analysis of the subreddit - changemyview dataset, the study found that:
- The retaliation rate of southern users when personally attacked is significantly higher than that of non - southern users (+5.6%).
- The mixed - effects model shows that southern users are more likely to retaliate (odds ratio of 1.2 ± 0.1, p - value < 0.002).

### Discussion and Limitations
- The study is limited to English - speaking users in the United States and on Reddit, and there may be errors in geographical location information.
- The application of cultural labels needs to be cautious, avoiding applying broad cultural labels to individuals.
- The research results show that southern users are more likely to exhibit verbal violence in online interactions to protect their reputation.

### Ethical Statement
The study is based on publicly available datasets and does not involve human subject research, so it does not require review by an ethics committee.

Through this study, the author successfully verified the theoretical prediction about the "culture of honor" in the American South and demonstrated the application potential of large - scale language models in social science analysis.