Report on Female Participation in Informatics degrees in Europe

Andrea D'Angelo,Tiziana Catarci,Antinisca Di Marco,Monica Landoni,Enrico Nardelli,Giovanni Stilo

2024-10-15

Abstract:This study aims to enrich and leverage data from the Informatics Europe Higher Education (IEHE) data portal to extract and analyze trends in female participation in Informatics across Europe. The research examines the proportion of female students, first-year enrollments, and degrees awarded to women in the field. The issue of low female participation in Informatics has long been recognized as a persistent challenge and remains a critical area of scholarly inquiry. Furthermore, existing literature indicates that socio-economic factors can unpredictably influence female participation, complicating efforts to address the gender gap. The analysis focuses on participation data from research universities at various academic levels, including Bachelors, Masters, and PhD programs, and seeks to uncover potential correlations between female participation and geographical or economic zones. The dataset was first enriched by integrating additional information, such as each country's GDP and relevant geographical data, sourced from various online repositories. Subsequently, the data was cleaned to ensure consistency and eliminate incomplete time series. A final set of complete time series was selected for further analysis. We then used the data collected from the internet to assign countries to different clusters. Specifically, we employed Economic Zone, Geographical Area, and GDP quartile to cluster countries and compare their temporal trends both within and between clusters. We analyze the results for each classification and derive conclusions based on the available data.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to analyze and understand the participation of women in informatics (computer science) degree programs in European countries, especially to explore the reasons for the low proportion of women's participation and its relationship with economic, geographical and other factors. Specifically, the research aims to:

1. **Extract and analyze trends**: Use the data from the Higher Education Data Portal of Informatics Europe to analyze the changing trends of the proportion of women's participation in the informatics field, the number of new students enrolled, and the number of degrees awarded.
2. **Explore influencing factors**: Study the influence of socio - economic factors (such as GDP, economic regions, geographical regions, etc.) on women's participation in informatics education to reveal possible correlations.
3. **Identify anomalies**: Through cluster analysis, find out the anomalies of women's participation in informatics education in countries with different economic regions, geographical regions and GDP levels, and explore the reasons behind them.

### Main problems:
- **Low participation rate**: For a long time, the low participation rate of women in the informatics field has been a persistent challenge. The research attempts to explain this phenomenon and find solutions.
- **Socio - economic impact**: Existing literature shows that socio - economic factors may unpredictably affect the degree of women's participation in informatics, making it more complicated to solve the gender gap problem.

### Research methods:
To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the researchers took the following steps:
1. **Data collection and expansion**: Obtain additional data from multiple online resources, such as the GDP and geographical location of each country, to enrich the original data set.
2. **Data cleaning**: Remove incomplete time - series data to ensure that the data used for analysis is complete and consistent.
3. **Classification and cluster analysis**: Classify countries according to economic regions, geographical regions and GDP levels, and conduct cluster analysis to compare the trend differences between different types of countries.

### Key findings:
- **Economic region analysis**: Although there is no obvious correlation between different economic regions, some countries (such as Romania and Latvia) show significant outliers.
- **Economic region analysis**: Nordic countries have a higher participation rate of women at the master's and doctoral levels, while southern and western European countries are relatively low.
- **GDP level analysis**: Most strikingly, the countries with the lowest GDP have the highest participation rate of women at all academic levels, which is counter - intuitive but in line with some previous research results.

### Conclusion:
Despite some counter - intuitive results, the research finally reveals the complex relationship between GDP level and women's participation in informatics education. These findings provide valuable insights for future further exploration of gender equality and technical education.