Abstract:When decisions are made at high frequency, traditional reinforcement learning (RL) methods struggle to accurately estimate action values. In turn, their performance is inconsistent and often poor. Whether the performance of distributional RL (DRL) agents suffers similarly, however, is unknown. In this work, we establish that DRL agents are sensitive to the decision frequency. We prove that action-conditioned return distributions collapse to their underlying policy's return distribution as the decision frequency increases. We quantify the rate of collapse of these return distributions and exhibit that their statistics collapse at different rates. Moreover, we define distributional perspectives on action gaps and advantages. In particular, we introduce the superiority as a probabilistic generalization of the advantage -- the core object of approaches to mitigating performance issues in high-frequency value-based RL. In addition, we build a superiority-based DRL algorithm. Through simulations in an option-trading domain, we validate that proper modeling of the superiority distribution produces improved controllers at high decision frequencies.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue that traditional Reinforcement Learning (RL) methods struggle to accurately estimate action values in high-frequency decision-making scenarios, leading to unstable and often poor performance. Specifically, the paper explores whether Distributed Reinforcement Learning (DRL) agents are similarly affected by decision frequency and provides theoretical and empirical analyses to demonstrate the sensitivity of DRL agents' performance in high-frequency decision-making. ### Main Contributions: 1. **Distributional Action Gap**: - Extends the concept of action gap to the field of distributed reinforcement learning, considering the minimum distance between distributions under different action conditions. - Observes that some metrics are applicable to this extension, while others are not. 2. **Collapse of Distributional Control at High Frequency**: - Establishes tight bounds on the distributional action gap of action-conditioned return distributions that depend on the time step \( h \). - Demonstrates that these distributional action gaps collapse not only as \( h \) approaches zero but also more slowly than the action value gaps. 3. **Distributional Superiority**: - Proposes a concept of distributional superiority as a probabilistic generalization of the advantage function. - Introduces a frequency-scaled superiority distribution that allows for greedy action selection at any fixed decision frequency. 4. **A Distributional Action Gap-Preserving Algorithm**: - Proposes an algorithm to learn the superiority distribution from data. - Empirical evidence shows that this algorithm can more reliably perform policy optimization under high-frequency decision-making. ### Specific Issues: - **Performance Sensitivity in High-Frequency Decision-Making**: The paper theoretically and empirically demonstrates that DRL agents' performance is indeed affected by decision frequency, especially in terms of action value estimation. - **Measurement of Action Gap**: Introduces the concept of distributional action gap and discusses the impact of different metric choices on the results. - **Superiority Distribution**: Introduces the superiority distribution as a method to improve high-frequency decision-making performance and demonstrates its effectiveness through experiments. ### Application Scenarios: - **Financial Trading**: In high-frequency trading, the decision frequency is very high, and traditional RL methods may fail to accurately estimate action values, leading to performance degradation. The superiority distribution method proposed in the paper can improve this situation. - **Robotic Control**: In real-time control systems, high-frequency decision-making is common, and the methods proposed in the paper can help improve system stability and performance. ### Conclusion: Through theoretical and empirical analyses, the paper demonstrates the performance sensitivity of DRL agents in high-frequency decision-making scenarios and proposes a new method—superiority distribution—to improve performance under high-frequency decision-making. This provides new insights and tools for the application of reinforcement learning in high-frequency decision-making scenarios.

Action Gaps and Advantages in Continuous-Time Distributional Reinforcement Learning

Normality-Guided Distributional Reinforcement Learning for Continuous Control

Taming "data-hungry" reinforcement learning? Stability in continuous state-action spaces

On the Foundation of Distributionally Robust Reinforcement Learning

Learn Continuously, Act Discretely: Hybrid Action-Space Reinforcement Learning For Optimal Execution

Continuous Control Reinforcement Learning: Distributed Distributional DrQ Algorithms

Bridging the gap between Markowitz planning and deep reinforcement learning

Non-crossing quantile regression for deep reinforcement learning

A Distributional Perspective on Reinforcement Learning

Off-Policy Reinforcement Learning with High Dimensional Reward

Assessing the Impact of Distribution Shift on Reinforcement Learning Performance

Deep Reinforcement Learning Strategies in Finance: Insights into Asset Holding, Trading Behavior, and Purchase Diversity

Dynamic Decision Frequency with Continuous Options

Learning Agents With Prioritization and Parameter Noise in Continuous State and Action Space

Distributional Reinforcement Learning With Quantile Regression

Efficient Continuous Space Policy Optimization for High-frequency Trading

Managing Temporal Resolution in Continuous Value Estimation: A Fundamental Trade-off

How Does Value Distribution in Distributional Reinforcement Learning Help Optimization?

Deep Reinforcement Trading with Predictable Returns

Bridging RL Theory and Practice with the Effective Horizon

Distributional Reinforcement Learning for Efficient Exploration