Abstract:This work analyses the interdependent link creation of patent and shareholding links in interfirm networks, and how this dynamics affects the resilience of such networks in the face of cascading failures. Using the Orbis dataset, we construct very large co-patenting and shareholding networks, globally as well as in terms of individual countries. Besides, we construct smaller overlap networks from those firm pairs which have both types of links between them, for nine years between 2008-2016. We use information theoretic measures, such as mutual information, active information storage, and transfer entropy, to characterise the topological similarities and shared topological information between the relevant co-patenting and shareholding networks. We then construct a cascading failure model, and use it to analyse the resilience of interdependent interfirm networks in terms of multiple failure characteristics. We find that there is relatively high level of mutual information between co-patenting networks and the shareholding networks from later years, suggesting that the formation of shareholding links is influenced by the existence of patent links in previous years. We also show that this influence becomes most apparent after a delay of four years between the formation of co-patenting links and shareholding links. Analysing the resilience of shareholding networks against cascading failures, we show that in terms of both mean downtime, and failure proportion of firms, certain countries have less resilient shareholding networks compared to other countries with significant economies. Based on our results, we postulate that an interfirm network model which considers multiple types of relationships together could be a to highlight important features of economic systems around the world.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand the interdependent relationship between co - patenting networks and shareholding networks among enterprises, and how this interdependence affects the resilience of these networks when cascading failures occur.
Specifically, the paper explores this problem through the following two aspects:
1. **Interdependence and co - evolution of inter - enterprise networks**:
- The paper uses information - theoretic measures (such as mutual information, active information storage, and transfer entropy) to study whether the edge formation in the patent cooperation network can provide information about the edge formation in the shareholding network, and vice versa.
- The authors also analyze the differences in this relationship among different countries and find that the inter - enterprise networks in some countries (such as Switzerland and the Netherlands) show stronger correlations. In addition, they find that this influence is usually most obvious about four years after the formation of patent cooperation links.
2. **Resilience of inter - enterprise networks to cascading failures**:
- The paper develops a cascading failure model applicable to the shareholding network to simulate the impact of economic shocks on the inter - enterprise network.
- Through simulation experiments, the authors evaluate the resilience of inter - enterprise networks in different countries when facing cascading failures. The results show that the shareholding networks in some countries (such as Italy, Germany, India, Japan, and the United States) have poor resilience under economic shocks.
### Main methods
- **Data sources**: The paper uses the Orbis database, which contains data on more than 400 million companies worldwide, with a time span from 1895 to 2016.
- **Network construction**:
- **Patent cooperation network**: Nodes represent companies, and edges represent cooperation between companies on the same patent. This network is an undirected graph.
- **Shareholding network**: Nodes represent companies, and edges represent that one company directly or indirectly holds shares in another company. This network is a directed graph.
- **Overlapping network**: In order to compare the edge formation between the two networks, the paper constructs an "overlapping network", that is, a sub - network of companies with both patent cooperation and shareholding relationships.
- **Information - theoretic analysis**: Use information - theoretic measures such as mutual information and transfer entropy to quantify the causal relationship between the two networks.
- **Cascading failure simulation**: Develop a cascading failure model based on a random process to simulate the impact of economic shocks on the inter - enterprise network and evaluate its resilience.
### Conclusions
The research results of the paper show that there is a significant interdependent relationship between the patent cooperation network and the shareholding network, and this relationship varies among different countries. In addition, the shareholding networks in some countries are more vulnerable when facing cascading failures. These findings provide a new perspective for understanding the complex relationships in the global economic system and provide a reference for future economic policy - making.
### Formula summary
- **Mutual information**:
\[
I(X;Y)=\sum_{y\in Y}\sum_{x\in X}P(X,Y)(x,y)\log\left(\frac{P(X,Y)(x,y)}{P_X(x)P_Y(y)}\right)
\]
- **Active information storage**:
\[
A_X(k)=I\left(X_n^{(k)};X_{n + 1}\right)
\]
- **Transfer entropy**:
\[
T_{Y\rightarrow X}(k,l,\tau_X,\tau_Y,u)=I\left(Y_{n + 1 - u}^{(l,\tau_Y)};X_{n + 1}\mid X_n^{(k,\tau_X)}\right)
\]
These formulas are used to quantify the information transfer and causal relationship between the two networks.