Abstract:While disproven by S. Carnot 200 years ago, corpuscularianism (the philosophy that the states of individual molecules determine the state of a system of those molecules) is still widely used to describe biological function. Nowhere is this more evident than in proposed power stroke mechanisms of muscle contraction. Muscle's power stroke occurs when muscle shortens against a mechanical load, performing work over time. While many mechanisms have been proposed, the actual power stroke mechanism of muscle contraction remains contested. Here I consider four distinctly different proposed mechanisms and assess their history and scientific merit. I show that over the past 65 years, molecular biologists have ignored Carnot for their corpuscular mechanic convictions in proposing a series of molecular power stroke mechanisms that regress from 19th century thermodynamics to an obsolete 17th century philosophy to a structural determinism invoked today that predates science. An isothermal power stroke in a thermodynamic muscle work loop, analogous to the power stoke in a Carnot cycle, rectifies this historic scientific blunder, defining the confluence of the bottom-up mechanics and chemistry of myosin motors and the top-down mechanics and chemistry of muscle. Specifically, created by thermal scaling, the increase in entropy with muscle's thermodynamic power stroke chemically exists within muscle and defines the irreversible energetics and kinetics of muscle contraction (the arrow of time).

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper primarily explores the issue of the power stroke mechanism in muscle contraction and attempts to correct the long-standing misconceptions in the field of molecular biology regarding this issue. 1. **Background and Current Status**: - During muscle contraction, muscles work against mechanical loads, i.e., the power stroke. Although many mechanisms have been proposed, the actual power stroke mechanism remains controversial. - Molecular biologists generally ignore the Carnot theorem, believing that the state of individual molecules can determine the state of the entire system, leading to many molecular mechanism-based power stroke models, but these models have not been validated. 2. **Core Issues**: - Researchers have proposed 4 different power stroke mechanisms and evaluated their historical and scientific value. - Researchers point out that molecular biologists have adhered to the molecular mechanics perspective for the past 65 years, ignoring the fundamental principles of thermodynamics. 3. **Solutions**: - The paper proposes an isothermal power stroke mechanism, similar to the isothermal expansion process in the Carnot cycle. This mechanism addresses the historical misunderstandings of the muscle power stroke mechanism. - Through a thermodynamic model, researchers demonstrate that the muscle power stroke is driven by an entropy-increasing process that occurs within the muscle, defining the irreversible dynamic characteristics of muscle contraction. 4. **Challenges and Reflections**: - The paper emphasizes the molecular biology community's neglect of the Carnot theorem and thermodynamics, pointing out that this neglect has led to long-term scientific misconceptions. - Researchers call for a return to fundamental physical principles, re-examining the mechanism of muscle contraction, and propose a simple and effective two-state thermodynamic model to explain the key aspects of muscle contraction. In summary, this paper aims to correct the long-standing misconceptions in the molecular biology community regarding the power stroke mechanism of muscle contraction and proposes a new mechanism based on thermodynamic principles.

The Power Stroke Mechanism of Muscle Contraction at the Confluence of Biology and Physics

The Kinetic and Energetic Pull of Chemical Entropy

Mechanics of the power stroke in myosin II

Four phases of a force transient emerge from a binary mechanical system

Coulomb Interaction as the Source of Muscle Force

Quantized Thermodynamics, Nested Resonant Structures, and the Entropic Stability of Life

Motor Force Homeostasis in Skeletal Muscle Contraction

Active hydraulics and odd elasticity of muscle fibers

Myosin's powerstroke transitions define atomic scale movement of cardiac thin filament tropomyosin

Power strokes in molecular motors: Predictive, irrelevant, or somewhere in between?

More ATP Does Not Equal More Contractility: Power And Remodelling In Reconstituted Actomyosin

Beyond power limits: the kinetic energy capacity of skeletal muscle

Energetics of muscle contraction: the whole is less than the sum of its parts

Stochastic Ratcheting on a Funneled Energy Landscape is Necessary for Highly Efficient Contractility of Actomyosin Force Dipoles

Research on Biomechanical Model of Muscle Fiber Based on Four-State Operating Mechanism of Molecular Motors.

The energy of muscle contraction. I. Tissue force and deformation during isometric contractions

Studies on Biomechanics of Skeletal Muscle Based on the Working Mechanism of Myosin Motors：an Overview

Mixed-scale versus multiscale models of muscle contraction

Mechanisms of myosin II force generation. Insights from novel experimental techniques and approaches

On the rate-limiting dynamics of force development in muscle

Mechanosensing in myosin filament solves a 60 years old conflict in skeletal muscle modeling between high power output and slow rise in tension