Open loop calibration and closed loop non-perturbative estimation of the lateral errors of an adaptive optics system: examples with GRAVITY+ and CHARA experimental data

Anthony Berdeu,Henri Bonnet,Jean-Baptiste Le Bouquin,Johann Kolb,Guillaume Bourdarot,Philippe Berio,Thibaut Paumard,Frank Eisenhauer,Christian Straubmeier,Paulo Garcia,Sebastian Hönig,Florentin Millour,Laura Kreidberg,Denis Defrère,Ferréol Soulez,Denis Mourard,Gail Schaefer,Narsireddy Anugu

2024-10-09

Abstract:Performances of an adaptive optics (AO) system are directly linked with the quality of its alignment. During the instrument calibration, having open loop fast tools with a large capture range are necessary to quickly assess the system misalignment and to drive it towards a state allowing to close the AO loop. During operation, complex systems are prone to misalignments (mechanical flexions, rotation of optical elements, etc.) that potentially degrade the AO performances, creating a need for a monitoring tool to tackle their driftage. In this work, we first present an improved perturbative method to quickly assess large lateral errors in open loop. It uses the spatial correlation of the measured interaction matrix of a limited number of 2D spatial modes with a synthetic model. Then, we introduce a novel solution to finely measure and correct these lateral errors via the closed loop telemetry. Non-perturbative, this method consequently does not impact the science output of the instrument. It is based on the temporal correlation of 2D spatial frequencies in the deformable mirror commands. It is model-free (no need of an interaction matrix model) and sparse in the Fourier space, making it fast and easily scalable to complex systems such as future extremely large telescopes. Finally, we present some results obtained on the development bench of the GRAVITY+ extreme AO system (Cartesian grid, 1432 actuators). In addition, we show with on-sky results gathered with CHARA and GRAVITY/CIAO that the method is adaptable to non-conventional AO geometries (hexagonal grids, 60 actuators).

Signal Processing,Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problems of calibration and monitoring of lateral errors in Adaptive Optics (AO) systems. Specifically, it proposes two methods to evaluate and correct the lateral errors of AO systems:

1. **Fast evaluation method in open - loop**:
- **Background**: During instrument calibration, it is necessary to quickly evaluate the misalignment of the system and adjust it to a state where the AO loop can be closed.
- **Method**: An improved perturbation method is proposed. By measuring the spatial correlation between a limited number of 2D spatial modes and a synthetic model, large lateral errors can be quickly evaluated.
- **Advantage**: It has a large capture range and is suitable for calibration and preset in the open - loop.

2. **Closed - loop non - perturbation estimation method**:
- **Background**: During operation, complex systems are prone to problems such as mechanical deformation and rotation of optical elements, which lead to a decline in AO performance. Therefore, a real - time monitoring tool is required to deal with these drifts.
- **Method**: A new 2D spatial - frequency - time - correlation - based solution using the commands of the deformable mirror is introduced, which can finely measure and correct lateral errors in the closed - loop.
- **Advantage**: It does not require an interaction matrix model, does not interfere with scientific observations, is sparse in Fourier space, has a fast calculation speed, and is easy to extend to complex systems (such as future extremely large telescopes).

### Key contributions
- **Open - loop method**: Use spatial correlation to evaluate lateral errors, with a large capture range, suitable for the calibration stage.
- **Closed - loop method**: Based on time - correlation analysis, monitor and correct lateral errors in real - time without affecting scientific data collection.
- **Experimental verification**: Experimental verification was carried out on the GRAVITY+ development platform (GPAO), and the results of actual sky data from CHARA and GRAVITY/CIAO were shown, proving the effectiveness and adaptability of the methods.

### Application prospects
These methods will be the core part for the automatic alignment strategy of the GPAO system, especially in the application of future extremely large telescopes (ELTs), which can significantly improve the stability and performance of adaptive optics systems.

### Formula summary
- **Formula of the open - loop method**:
\[
\alpha(\delta) = \argmin_{\beta} \sum_{x,m} w(x,\delta) \left( \tilde{M}_{\text{int}}^m(x) - \beta M_{\text{int}}^m(x-\delta) \right)^2
\]
\[
\alpha(\delta) = \frac{\sum_{x,m} w(x,\delta) \tilde{M}_{\text{int}}^m(x) M_{\text{int}}^m(x-\delta)}{\sum_{x,m} w(x,\delta) \left[ M_{\text{int}}^m(x-\delta) \right]^2}
\]

- **Formula of the closed - loop method**:
\[
C_{c_1,c_2}(k, f) \triangleq \frac{\langle c_1(k, f) c_2(k, f) \rangle}{\sqrt{V_{c_1}(k, f) V_{c_2}(k, f)}}
\]
\[
\tilde{\delta} = \argmin_{\delta} \sum_{k \in K_{\text{ctrl}}, f > 0} \left( \tilde{C}_{\text{cl}}(k, f) - 2\pi C_0(f) k^T \cdot \delta \right)^2
\]

Through these methods, researchers aim to improve the alignment accuracy and stability of adaptive optics systems, thereby improving the quality and efficiency of astronomical observations.