The Rise of Health Economics: Transforming the Landscape of Economic Research

Lorenz Gschwent,Björn Hammarfelt,Martin Karlsson,Mathias Kifmann

2024-10-09

Abstract:This paper explores the evolving role of health economics within economic research and publishing over the past 30 years. Historically largely a niche field, health economics has become increasingly prominent, with the share of health economics papers in top journals growing significantly. We aim to identify the factors behind this rise, examining how health economics contributes to the broader economic knowledge base and the roles distinct subfields play. Using a combination of bibliometric methods and natural language processing, we classify abstracts to define health economics. Our findings suggest that the mainstreaming of health economics is driven by innovative, high-quality research, with notable cyclicality in quality ratings that highlights the emergence and impact of distinct subfields within the discipline.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the evolution of the role of health economics in economic research and publication over the past 30 years and the reasons for its increasing importance. Specifically, the authors aim to answer the following questions:

1. **Factors in the Rise of Health Economics**: Why has health economics risen rapidly from a relatively niche research area to an important branch in economic research in the past few decades? What factors have driven this change?

2. **Contribution to Overall Economic Knowledge**: How does health economics contribute to the broader economic knowledge base? What role does it play in economic research?

3. **Contributions of Different Sub - fields**: What roles have different sub - fields within health economics (such as health policy, medical markets, health behavior, etc.) played in this process? Do these sub - fields have periodic quality fluctuations and have a lasting impact on economic research?

### Main Methods

To answer these questions, the authors adopted multiple methods:

- **Bibliometric Methods**: By analyzing the proportion of papers published in top - tier economic journals over the past 30 years, reveal the growth trend of the number of health economics papers.

- **Natural Language Processing (NLP)**: Use large - scale Transformer - based language models such as RoBERTa to classify paper titles and abstracts to determine which papers belong to the field of health economics. This method combines journal - based classification and author - based classification, improving the accuracy and reliability of classification.

- **Novelty, Impact, and Quality Assessment**: Draw on the method of Kelly et al. (2021) to assess the novelty, impact, and quality of papers by calculating the similarity between a paper and its preceding and following papers. The specific formulas are as follows:

- **Backward Similarity (BSi)**:
\[
BS_i=\text{sim}(v_i,\bar{u}_i(- 5,-1))
\]
where \(v_i\) is the vector representation of paper \(i\), and \(\bar{u}_i(a,b)\) is the average vector representation of all papers published within \(a\) to \(b\) years before the publication of paper \(i\).

- **Forward Similarity (FSi)**:
\[
FS_i = \text{sim}(v_i,\bar{u}_i(1,5))
\]
where \(\bar{u}_i(a,b)\) is the average vector representation of all papers published within \(a\) to \(b\) years after the publication of paper \(i\).

- **Quality (Qi)**:
\[
Q_i=FS_i - BS_i
\]

- **Novelty (Ni)**:
\[
N_i = PS_i - BS_i
\]
where \(PS_i\) is the similarity of paper \(i\) to papers published in the same year.

- **Impact (Ii)**:
\[
I_i=FS_i - PS_i
\]

Through these methods, the authors not only revealed the trends in the quality and influence of health economics papers but also discovered the contributions of different sub - fields in different time periods.

### Conclusions

The research shows that the rise of health economics is mainly attributed to innovative and high - quality research. In particular, in some key years, the novelty and influence of health economics papers have increased significantly, thus promoting the progress of the entire economic field. In addition, different sub - fields have played important roles in the overall development of health economics at different times.