Corrections to "Computer Vision Aided mmWave Beam Alignment in V2X Communications"

Weihua Xu,Feifei Gao,Xiaoming Tao,Jianhua Zhang,Ahmed Alkhateeb
2024-10-08
Abstract:In this document, we revise the results of [1] based on more reasonable assumptions regarding data shuffling and parameter setup of deep neural networks (DNNs). Thus, the simulation results can now more reasonably demonstrate the performance of both the proposed and compared beam alignment methods. We revise the simulation steps and make moderate modifications to the design of the vehicle distribution feature (VDF) for the proposed vision based beam alignment when the MS location is available (VBALA). Specifically, we replace the 2D grids of the VDF with 3D grids and utilize the vehicle locations to expand the dimensions of the VDF. Then, we revise the simulation results of Fig. 11, Fig. 12, Fig. 13, Fig. 14, and Fig. 15 in [1] to reaffirm the validity of the conclusions.
Signal Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to correct and improve the simulation results and designs of the millimeter - wave (mmWave) beam alignment methods in previous studies, especially the vision - assisted beam alignment method (VBALA) in vehicle - to - everything (V2X) communications. Specifically, the authors have made improvements in the following aspects: 1. **Data Shuffling and Parameter Settings**: In the original paper, the dataset was shuffled only once at the initialization during the training phase, which led to an unreasonable performance evaluation. The new paper modifies the training method to ensure that the dataset is shuffled in every epoch and adjusts some parameter settings of the deep neural network (DNN) to more reasonably demonstrate the performance of each method. 2. **Design of Vehicle Distribution Feature (VDF)**: The original paper used a two - dimensional - grid - based VDF. The new paper replaces it with a three - dimensional grid and extends the dimension of the VDF by using vehicle positions. Specifically, the cube RSU coverage area is divided into a 3D grid of \( GX\times GY\times GZ \), a local coordinate system (LCS) is set for each grid, and the average length, width, height, azimuth angle, and center coordinates of the vehicle are calculated according to its position. 3. **Correction of Simulation Results**: Multiple key charts in the original paper (such as Figure 11, Figure 12, Figure 13, Figure 14, and Figure 15) are regenerated to verify the validity of the conclusions. Through these corrections, the authors have found some differences from the original conclusions: - Under non - line - of - sight (NLOS) conditions, the performance degradation trend of multi - modal beam alignment (BMBA) is lower than that of VBALA. Therefore, BMBA can outperform VBALA at larger position errors. - Under line - of - sight (LOS) conditions, the performance of VBALA is slightly lower than that of BMBA, but it has advantages in computational complexity and environmental generalization ability. 4. **Supplementary Corrections**: Figure 15 in the original paper wrongly shows the verification accuracy of the predicted beam coherence time (VPBCT), and the new paper corrects this. In general, by improving data processing methods, optimizing feature designs, and re - evaluating simulation results, this paper aims to provide a more accurate and reasonable performance evaluation of millimeter - wave beam alignment, especially in V2X communication scenarios.