Crystal structure and absence of magnetic order in single crystalline RuO$_2$

Lara Kiefer,Felix Wirth,Alexandre Bertin,Petra Becker,Ladislav Bohatý,Karin Schmalzl,Anne Stunault,J. Alberto Rodríguez-Velamazán,Oscar Fabelo,Markus Braden

2024-10-08

Abstract:RuO$_2$ was considered for a long time to be a paramagnetic metal with an ideal rutile-type structure down to low temperatures, but recent studies on single-crystals claimed evidence for antiferromagnetic order and some symmetry breaking in the crystal structure. We have grown single-crystals of RuO2 by vapor transport using either O$_2$ or TeCl$_4$ as transport medium. These crystals exhibit metallic behavior following a $T^2$ low-temperature relation and a small paramagnetic susceptibility that can be attributed to Pauli paramagnetism. Neither the conductance nor the susceptibility measurements yield any evidence for a magnetic or a structural transition between 300K and $\sim$4 K. Comprehensive single-crystal diffraction studies with neutron and X-ray radiation reveal the rutile structure to persist until 2K in our crystals, and show nearly perfect stoichiometry. Previous observations of symmetry forbidden reflections can be attributed to multiple diffraction. Polarized single-crystal neutron diffraction experiments at 1.6K exclude the proposed antiferromagnetic structures with ordered moments larger than 0.01 Bohr magnetons.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on two aspects:

1. **Whether there is distortion in the crystal structure of RuO₂**: For a long time, RuO₂ has been considered to have an ideal rutile - type structure at low temperatures and is a paramagnetic metal. However, recent studies have shown that antiferromagnetic order and symmetry breaking of the crystal structure may exist in single - crystal RuO₂. Therefore, this study aims to verify whether these observations regarding structural distortion are valid by growing single - crystal RuO₂ and conducting detailed single - crystal diffraction experiments.

2. **Whether there is magnetic order in RuO₂**: RuO₂ was once considered to be a Pauli paramagnet, but recent studies have proposed the possibility of the existence of antiferromagnetic order in RuO₂, and some studies even claim that this magnetic order appears above room temperature. However, other experiments such as μSR (muon spin resonance) have not observed any evidence of magnetic order. Therefore, this study further explores whether there is magnetic order in RuO₂ and its properties through methods such as polarized neutron scattering experiments.

The paper conducted a detailed study of single - crystal RuO₂ by comprehensively using multiple techniques such as X - ray diffraction, neutron diffraction, and polarized neutron scattering. Finally, it concluded that RuO₂ maintains an ideal rutile - type structure in the temperature range from 2 K to 300 K, and no evidence of any magnetic order has been found, excluding previous reports on the existence of antiferromagnetic order. In addition, the study also confirmed that the RuO₂ samples almost perfectly conform to the stoichiometric ratio, with only a very small number of ruthenium vacancies. These results are helpful for clarifying the controversies regarding the magnetic and structural properties of RuO₂.