Interconnected Kingdoms: Comparing 'A Song of Ice and Fire' Adaptations Across Media Using Complex Networks

Arthur Amalvy,Madeleine Janickyj,Shane Mannion,Pádraig MacCarron,Vincent Labatut

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13278-024-01365-z

2024-10-08

Abstract:In this article, we propose and apply a method to compare adaptations of the same story across different media. We tackle this task by modelling such adaptations through character networks. We compare them by leveraging two concepts at the core of storytelling: the characters involved, and the dynamics of the story. We propose several methods to match characters between media and compare their position in the networks; and perform narrative matching, i.e. match the sequences of narrative units that constitute the plots. We apply these methods to the novel series \textit{A Song of Ice and Fire}, by G.R.R. Martin, and its comics and TV show adaptations. Our results show that interactions between characters are not sufficient to properly match individual characters between adaptations, but that using some additional information such as character affiliation or gender significantly improves the performance. On the contrary, character interactions convey enough information to perform narrative matching, and allow us to detect the divergence between the original novels and its TV show adaptation.

Social and Information Networks,Computation and Language

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the following problem: how to compare different adaptations of the same story across various media through character networks, specifically focusing on the following two research questions:

1. **Can characters in one adaptation be matched with characters in another adaptation based on their interactions?** (RQ1)
2. **Can these interactions be used to align the plots of different adaptations?** (RQ2)

To answer these research questions, the authors used the novel "A Song of Ice and Fire," the comic, and the TV series "Game of Thrones" as their study subjects. By constructing and analyzing the character networks of these adaptations, the authors aim to understand how different media influence the narrative style and character positioning.

Specifically, the main contributions of the paper include:
- Constructing a dataset of character networks that includes the novel, comic, and TV series.
- Formalizing the character matching task as a graph matching problem and applying existing graph matching methods for experiments.
- Proposing the concept of narrative matching, which involves aligning the plots of different adaptations, and presenting three different methods to address this issue.
- Introducing the concept of "blocks" as an intermediate time scale to represent plot segments in the TV series, thereby improving matching performance.

Through these methods, the authors hope to provide tools and methodologies for studying character and plot changes in the adaptation process.