Real-time cardiac cine MRI -- A comparison of a diffusion probabilistic model with alternative state-of-the-art image reconstruction techniques for undersampled spiral acquisitions

Oliver Schad,Julius Frederik Heidenreich,Nils-Christian Petri,Jonas Kleineisel,Simon Sauer,Thorsten Bley,Peter Nordbeck,Bernhard Petritsch,Tobias Wech
2024-10-07
Abstract:ECG-gated cine imaging in breath-hold enables high-quality diagnostics in most patients, arrhythmia and inability to hold breath, however, can severely corrupt outcomes. Real-time cardiac MRI in free-breathing leverages robust and faster investigations regardless of these confounding factors. With the need for sufficient acceleration, adequate reconstruction methods, which transfer data into high quality images, are required. Undersampled spiral real-time acquisitions in free-breathing were conducted in a study with 16 healthy volunteers and 5 patients. Image reconstructions were performed using a novel score-based diffusion model, as well as a variational network and different compressed sensing approaches. The techniques were compared by means of an expert reader study, by calculating scalar metrics and difference images with respect to a segmented reference, and by a Bland-Altman analysis of cardiac functional parameters. In participants with irregular RR-cycles, spiral real-time acquisitions showed superior image quality with respect to the clinical reference standard. Reconstructions using the diffusion model, the variational network and l1-wavelets offered an overall comparable image quality, however sharpness was slightly increased by the diffusion approach. While slightly larger ejection fractions for the real-time acquisitions were exhibited with a bias of 1.6% for healthy subjects, differences in the data acquisition procedure resulted in uncertainties of 7.4%. The proposed real-time technique enables free-breathing acquisitions of spatio-temporal images with high-quality, covering the entire heart in less than one minute. Evaluation of the ejection fractions using the segmented reference can be significantly corrupted due to arrhythmias and averaging effects. Prolonged inference times of the diffusion model represent the main obstacle to overcome for clinical translation.
Medical Physics,Image and Video Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve several key problems in real - time cardiac cine magnetic resonance imaging (cMRI): 1. **Motion Artifact Reduction**: For patients with arrhythmia or those unable to hold their breath, traditional segmented k - space sampling can lead to severe motion artifacts. Real - time cardiac cMRI can be performed during free breathing, thereby reducing these artifacts and improving image quality. 2. **Scan Time Reduction**: Real - time cardiac cMRI can significantly shorten the scan time, improve patient comfort, and reduce the overall scan cost, enabling more patients to receive cardiac MRI examinations. 3. **Accuracy of Dynamic Cardiac Motion**: By avoiding pooling data from multiple RR cycles, real - time cardiac cMRI can more accurately study dynamic cardiac motion, because the data in each RR cycle is not exactly the same and may be gated under sub - optimal conditions. 4. **Feasibility of Clinical Applications**: The paper explores techniques for reconstructing real - time cardiac cMRI data using diffusion models, variational networks, and other compressed sensing methods to evaluate their feasibility and image quality in clinical applications. Specifically, the paper addresses these problems through the following methods: - **Data Acquisition**: Use the spiral bSSFP sequence for undersampled real - time acquisition, combined with gradient waveform correction techniques to ensure data accuracy and efficiency. - **Image Reconstruction**: Propose a reconstruction method based on the diffusion probability model and compare it with variational networks, low - rank plus sparse algorithms, and compressed sensing methods based on total variation and wavelets. - **Performance Evaluation**: Comprehensively evaluate the image quality and clinical applicability of different methods through expert reading studies, scalar index calculations, difference image analysis, and Bland - Altman analysis of cardiac function parameters. The main conclusion of the paper is that the proposed real - time technique can complete spatio - temporal image acquisition of the whole heart in less than one minute and shows image quality superior to the clinical reference standard in participants with irregular RR cycles. However, the long - time inference of the diffusion model is the main obstacle to its clinical translation.