Enabling Clinical Use of Linear Energy Transfer in Proton Therapy for Head and Neck Cancer -- A Review of Implications for Treatment Planning and Adverse Events Study

Jingyuan Chen,Yunze Yang,Hongying Feng,Chenbin Liu,Lian Zhang,Jason M. Holmes,Zhengliang Liu,Haibo Lin,Tianming Liu,Charles B. Simone II,Nancy Y. Lee,Steven E. Frank,Daniel J. Ma,Samir H. Patel,Wei Liu

2024-10-06

Abstract:Proton therapy offers significant advantages due to its unique physical and biological properties, particularly the Bragg peak, enabling precise dose delivery to tumors while sparing healthy tissues. However, the clinical implementation is challenged by the oversimplification of the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) as a fixed value of 1.1, which does not account for the complex interplay between dose, linear energy transfer (LET), and biological endpoints. Lack of heterogeneity control or the understanding of the complex interplay may result in unexpected adverse events and suboptimal patient outcomes. On the other hand, expanding our knowledge of variable tumor RBE and LET optimization may provide a better management strategy for radioresistant tumors. This review examines recent advancements in LET calculation methods, including analytical models and Monte Carlo simulations. The integration of LET into plan evaluation is assessed to enhance plan quality control. LET-guided robust optimization demonstrates promise in minimizing high-LET exposure to organs at risk, thereby reducing the risk of adverse events. Dosimetric seed spot analysis is discussed to show its importance in revealing the true LET-related effect upon the adverse event initialization by finding the lesion origins and eliminating the confounding factors from the biological processes. Dose-LET volume histograms (DLVH) are discussed as effective tools for correlating physical dose and LET with clinical outcomes, enabling the derivation of clinically relevant dose-LET volume constraints without reliance on uncertain RBE models. Based on DLVH, the dose-LET volume constraints (DLVC)-guided robust optimization is introduced to upgrade conventional dose-volume constraints-based robust optimization, which optimizes the joint distribution of dose and LET simultaneously.

Medical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to make better use of Linear Energy Transfer (LET) in proton therapy for head and neck cancers to optimize treatment plans and reduce the occurrence of adverse events. Specifically, in current clinical practice, the Relative Biological Effectiveness (RBE) is usually simplified to a fixed value of 1.1, which ignores the complex interactions among dose, LET and biological endpoints, and may lead to unexpected adverse events and sub - optimal patient outcomes. Therefore, the paper explores how to improve the quality control of treatment plans by calculating and applying LET more accurately, especially by using the LET - guided robust optimization method to reduce the high - LET exposure of organs at risk, thereby reducing the risk of adverse events.

The paper also discusses the Dose - LET Volume Histogram (DLVH) as an effective tool for correlating physical dose and LET with clinical outcomes, and deriving clinically relevant Dose - LET Volume Constraints (DLVC) without relying on uncertain RBE models. These research advances aim to improve the understanding of LET - related biological mechanisms and develop clinically relevant LET - related volume constraints directly derived from clinical outcomes to guide future clinical practice.