Mean-field approximation on steroids: exact description of the deuteron
B. Bally,A. Scalesi,V. Somà ,L. Zurek,T. Duguet
2024-10-04
Abstract:The present article demonstrates that the deuteron, i.e. the lightest bound nuclear system made of a single proton and a single neutron, can be accurately described within a mean-field-based framework.
Although paradoxical at first glance, the deuteron ground-state binding energy, magnetic dipole moment, electric quadrupole moment and root-mean-square proton radius are indeed reproduced with sub-percent accuracy via a low-dimensional linear combination of non-orthogonal Bogoliubov states, i.e. with a method whose numerical cost scales as $n_{\text{dim}}^4$, where $n_{\text{dim}}$ is the dimension of the basis of the one-body Hilbert space. By further putting the system into a harmonic trap, the neutron-proton scattering length and effective range in the ${}^{3}S_1$ channel are also accurately reproduced.
To achieve this task, (i) the inclusion of proton-neutron pairing through the mixing of proton and neutron single-particle states in the Bogoliubov transformation and (ii) the restoration of proton and neutron numbers before variation are shown to be mandatory ingredients.
This unexpected result has implications regarding the most efficient way to capture necessary correlations as a function of nuclear mass and regarding the possibility to ensure order-by-order renormalizability of many-body calculations based on chiral or pionless effective field theories beyond light nuclei. In this context, the present study will be extended to $^{3}$H and $^{3,4}$He in the near future as well as to the leading order of pionless effective field theory.
Nuclear Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to accurately describe the deuteron (the lightest bound nuclear system consisting of one proton and one neutron) through an improved mean - field - based framework, especially by using the low - dimensional linear combination of non - orthogonal Bogoliubov states. Although on the surface this method seems to be contradictory to the accurate description of the deuteron, the authors show that through this method, the deuteron ground - state binding energy, magnetic dipole moment, electric quadrupole moment and the root - mean - square radius of the proton can be reproduced with an accuracy of less than 1%. In addition, by placing the system in a harmonic potential well, the proton - neutron scattering length and effective range in the 3S1 channel can also be accurately reproduced.
To achieve this goal, the authors emphasize two key elements:
1. **Proton - neutron pairing**: Proton - neutron pairing is introduced by mixing the single - particle states of protons and neutrons in the Bogoliubov transformation.
2. **Recovery of proton and neutron numbers**: Recover the proton and neutron numbers before variation.
These findings are of great significance for understanding how to effectively capture the necessary correlations at different nuclear masses and how to ensure the renormalizability of order - by - order in many - body calculations based on chiral or pion - less effective field theories beyond light nuclei. Future research will be further extended to the 3H and 3,4He systems, as well as the leading order of the pion - less effective field theory.
In conclusion, this research has successfully solved the problem of accurate description of the deuteron through the improved mean - field method and provided new ideas and methods for future calculations of more complex nuclear systems.