Abstract:The expected regret and target semi-variance are two of the most important risk measures for downside risk. When the distribution of a loss is uncertain, and only partial information of the loss is known, their worst-case values play important roles in robust risk management for finance, insurance, and many other fields. Jagannathan (1977) derived the worst-case expected regrets when only the mean and variance of a loss are known and the loss is arbitrary, symmetric, or non-negative. While Chen et al. (2011) obtained the worst-case target semi-variances under similar conditions but focusing on arbitrary losses. In this paper, we first complement the study of Chen et al. (2011) on the worst-case target semi-variances and derive the closed-form expressions for the worst-case target semi-variance when only the mean and variance of a loss are known and the loss is symmetric or non-negative. Then, we investigate worst-case target semi-variances over uncertainty sets that represent undesirable scenarios faced by an investors. Our methods for deriving these worst-case values are different from those used in Jagannathan (1977) and Chen et al. (2011). As applications of the results derived in this paper, we propose robust portfolio selection methods that minimize the worst-case target semi-variance of a portfolio loss over different uncertainty sets. To explore the insights of our robust portfolio selection methods, we conduct numerical experiments with real financial data and compare our portfolio selection methods with several existing portfolio selection models related to the models proposed in this paper.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the calculation problem of the worst - case target semi - variance under the uncertainty set, especially in fields such as finance and insurance, when the loss distribution is unknown and only partial information is known, how to conduct robust risk management. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to derive the closed - form expression of the worst - case target semi - variance for any, symmetric or non - negative loss distributions when only the mean and variance of the losses are known, and apply it to robust portfolio selection methods.
### Main contributions of the paper
1. **Supplementary research**: The paper first supplements the research on the worst - case target semi - variance by Chen et al. (2011), and derives the closed - form expression of the worst - case target semi - variance for symmetric or non - negative loss distributions when only the mean and variance of the losses are known.
2. **New method**: The method proposed in the paper is different from those of Jagannathan (1977) and Chen et al. (2011), and can handle more complex situations, such as symmetric and non - negative distributions.
3. **Application to portfolio selection**: Based on the derived worst - case target semi - variance, the paper proposes several robust portfolio selection methods, which aim to minimize the worst - case target semi - variance under different uncertainty sets. In particular, the paper proposes portfolio selection models based on the expected excess profit - target semi - variance (EEP - TSV), and these models can be transformed into optimization problems for minimizing the worst - case target semi - variance.
### Specific problems
- **Symmetric distribution**: The paper solves the worst - case target semi - variance problem under the symmetric distribution, that is:
\[
\sup_{F \in L_S(\mu, \sigma)} E_F[(X - t)^2_+]
\]
where \( L_S(\mu, \sigma) \) is the uncertainty set of the symmetric distribution.
- **Non - negative distribution**: The paper also solves the worst - case target semi - variance problem under the non - negative distribution, that is:
\[
\sup_{F \in L_+(\mu, \sigma)} E_F[(X - t)^2_+]
\]
where \( L_+(\mu, \sigma) \) is the uncertainty set of the non - negative distribution.
- **Undesirable scenarios**: The paper further studies the worst - case target semi - variance problem under undesirable scenarios, that is:
\[
\sup_{F \in L_\lambda(\mu, \sigma)} E_F[(X - t)^2_+]
\]
where \( L_\lambda(\mu, \sigma) \) is an uncertainty set that includes symmetric and non - negative distributions, and the expected excess profit does not exceed a certain threshold \(\lambda\).
### Application examples
The paper verifies the effectiveness of the proposed robust portfolio selection methods through numerical experiments, and compares them with several existing portfolio selection models. These experiments use real financial data and show the advantages of the new methods in practical applications.
### Conclusion
By deriving the closed - form expressions of the worst - case target semi - variance under different uncertainty sets, the paper provides new tools and methods for robust risk management in the fields of finance and insurance. These methods are not only of great theoretical significance but also of high value in practical applications.