Abstract:In <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="1811.01577" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.01577">arXiv:1811.01577</a> the VOAs associated to 4d $\mathcal{N}=2$ class-S theories were constructed in addition to a generalization for non-simply laced Lie algebras. However, 6d (2,0) theories have an ADE classification, and therefore class-S theories which are engineered by them come in ADE types. Thus, these non-simply laced VOAs are not thought to correspond to 4d physical theories. Regardless, we analyze these VOAs and their Drinfeld-Sokolov reductions in an effort to determine their properties. We find that many of these reduced VOAs appear to correspond to actual 4d $\mathcal{N}=2$ SCFTs. Additionally, we find what appear to be $F_4$ instanton VOAs, and hence from the proposal of <a class="link-https" data-arxiv-id="2201.13435" href="https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.13435">arXiv:2201.13435</a> these correspond to 3d $\mathcal{N}=4$ quiver gauge theories whose Coulomb branches are $F_4$ instanton moduli spaces. Using a construction of twisted class-S VOAs from non-simply laced ones, we find additional evidence that the $F_4$ instanton VOAs do not correspond to four-dimensional field theories and outline an analogous argument for the $G_2$ instanton case. Our method appears to be quite general and may be a promising technique for ruling out 4d origins of VOAs that are similar to those of 4d $\mathcal{N}=2$ SCFTs, in addition to constructing VOAs of actual 4d theories.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the properties of non - simply - connected class - S vertex operator algebras (VOAs) and their relationships with four - dimensional N = 2 superconformal field theories (SCFTs). Specifically:
1. **Analysis of non - simply - connected class - S VOAs**: The paper first analyzes these non - simply - connected class - S VOAs and their Drinfeld - Sokolov reductions to determine their properties. The author finds that many of these reduced VOAs seem to correspond to actual four - dimensional N = 2 SCFTs.
2. **Identification of F4 instanton VOAs**: The paper also discovers the structures that seem to be F4 instanton VOAs, and according to the suggestion in reference [2], believes that these VOAs correspond to 3d N = 4 quark gauge theories, whose Coulomb branches are F4 instanton moduli spaces.
3. **Discussion of G2 instanton VOAs**: By constructing twisted class - S VOAs, the author further provides evidence indicating that F4 instanton VOAs do not correspond to four - dimensional field theories, and outlines the argument for the similar G2 instanton case.
4. **Exclusion of 4d origin**: The paper proposes a general method that can be used to exclude the four - dimensional origin of VOAs similar to 4d N = 2 SCFTs, and can also construct VOAs of actual 4d theories.
### Main research contents
1. **Construction and properties of VOAs**:
- The paper discusses in detail how to construct non - simply - connected class - S VOAs, and analyzes their central charges, flavor symmetries, and other properties.
- Through Drinfeld - Sokolov reduction, the author obtains new VOAs and studies the properties of these VOAs.
2. **F4 and G2 instanton VOAs**:
- The author discovers some F4 instanton VOAs, and by comparing central charges, current algebra levels, and characteristic functions, finds that they match known 4d SCFTs.
- For G2 instanton VOAs, the author also conducts a similar analysis, but finds that they do not correspond to any known 4d theories.
3. **Duality and exclusion mechanism**:
- The paper explores various dualities, especially those involving twisted class - S VOAs, which help to exclude the 4d origin of many non - simply - connected VOAs.
- The author also discusses the phenomenon of constructing isolated SCFTs by gauging the current algebras of these VOAs.
### Conclusion
The main conclusion of the paper is that although non - simply - connected class - S VOAs can correspond to known 4d N = 2 SCFTs in some cases, there are also many VOAs that do not correspond to any known 4d theories. In particular, although F4 and G2 instanton VOAs have properties similar to 4d theories, through duality and other methods, it is possible to exclude their possibility as VOAs of 4d theories. This research provides important insights into understanding the properties of these VOAs and their roles in field theories of different dimensions.