Universal quantum theory contains twisted logic

Francesco Atzori,Enrico Rebufello,Maria Violaris,Laura T. Knoll,Abdulla Alhajri,Alessio Avella,Marco Gramegna,Chiara Marletto,Vlatko Vedral,Fabrizio Piacentini,Ivo Pietro Degiovanni,Marco Genovese
2024-10-01
Abstract:Quantum theory is notoriously counterintuitive, and yet remains entirely self-consistent when applied universally. Here we uncover a new manifestation of its unusual consequences. We demonstrate, theoretically and experimentally (by means of polarization-encoded single-photon qubits), that Heisenberg's uncertainty principle leads to the impossibility of stringing together logical deductions about outcomes of consecutive non-compatible measurements. This phenomenon resembles the geometry of a Penrose triangle, where each corner is locally consistent while the global structure is impossible. Besides this, we show how overlooking this non-trivial logical structure leads to the erroneous possibility of distinguishing non-orthogonal states with a single measurement.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?