Understanding How Psychological Distance Influences User Preferences in Conversational Versus Web Search

Yitian Yang,Yugin Tan,Yang Chen Lin,Jung-Tai King,Zihan Liu,Yi-Chieh Lee

2024-09-30

Abstract:Conversational search offers an easier and faster alternative to conventional web search, while having downsides like lack of source verification. Research has examined performance disparities between these two systems in different settings. However, little work has considered the effects of variations within a given search task. We hypothesize that psychological distance - one''s perceived closeness to a target event - affects information needs in search tasks, and investigate the corresponding effects on user preferences between web and conversational search systems. We find that with greater psychological distances, users perceive conversational search as more credible, useful, enjoyable, and easy to use, and demonstrate increased preference for this system. We reveal qualitative reasons for these differences and provide design implications for search system designers.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand how psychological distance affects users' preferences between dialogue search systems and traditional web search systems. Specifically, the research focuses on how psychological distance - that is, an individual's perceived proximity to a target event - affects information needs and, in turn, users' preferences in these two search systems. By manipulating the psychological distance dimensions of tasks (space, time, society, hypothesis), the research explores the differences in users' perceived credibility, usefulness, pleasure, and ease - of - use of these two search systems under different psychological distance conditions, and how these perceived differences affect users' system preferences. The research aims to fill the research gap in existing literature regarding how the nature of tasks affects technology preferences and provide important implications for the design of future information retrieval systems.