Privacy Attack in Federated Learning is Not Easy: An Experimental Study

Hangyu Zhu,Liyuan Huang,Zhenping Xie
2024-09-28
Abstract:Federated learning (FL) is an emerging distributed machine learning paradigm proposed for privacy preservation. Unlike traditional centralized learning approaches, FL enables multiple users to collaboratively train a shared global model without disclosing their own data, thereby significantly reducing the potential risk of privacy leakage. However, recent studies have indicated that FL cannot entirely guarantee privacy protection, and attackers may still be able to extract users' private data through the communicated model gradients. Although numerous privacy attack FL algorithms have been developed, most are designed to reconstruct private data from a single step of calculated gradients. It remains uncertain whether these methods are effective in realistic federated environments or if they have other limitations. In this paper, we aim to help researchers better understand and evaluate the effectiveness of privacy attacks on FL. We analyze and discuss recent research papers on this topic and conduct experiments in a real FL environment to compare the performance of various attack methods. Our experimental results reveal that none of the existing state-of-the-art privacy attack algorithms can effectively breach private client data in realistic FL settings, even in the absence of defense strategies. This suggests that privacy attacks in FL are more challenging than initially anticipated.
Cryptography and Security,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of the effectiveness of privacy attacks in Federated Learning (FL). Specifically, although Federated Learning is designed as a distributed machine learning method to protect user data privacy, recent studies have shown that Federated Learning cannot fully guarantee data privacy, and attackers may extract users' private data through the communicated model gradients. However, the effectiveness and limitations of these attack methods in practical Federated Learning environments remain unclear. To better understand and evaluate the effectiveness of these privacy attack methods in Federated Learning, the paper conducted the following research: 1. **Systematic Review**: A detailed discussion of existing privacy attack methods and their pros and cons. 2. **Experimental Evaluation**: Experiments on 9 representative privacy attack methods in a real Federated Learning environment to assess their performance in practical scenarios. Through these studies, the authors found that most existing privacy attack algorithms perform poorly in complex Federated Learning environments. Especially in the absence of defense strategies, these algorithms also struggle to successfully extract private client data. This indicates that privacy attacks in Federated Learning are much more challenging than initially expected.