Abstract:Inferring the exact parameters of a neural network with only query access is an NP-Hard problem, with few practical existing algorithms. Solutions would have major implications for security, verification, interpretability, and understanding biological networks. The key challenges are the massive parameter space, and complex non-linear relationships between neurons. We resolve these challenges using two insights. First, we observe that almost all networks used in practice are produced by random initialization and first order optimization, an inductive bias that drastically reduces the practical parameter space. Second, we present a novel query generation algorithm that produces maximally informative samples, letting us untangle the non-linear relationships efficiently. We demonstrate reconstruction of a hidden network containing over 1.5 million parameters, and of one 7 layers deep, the largest and deepest reconstructions to date, with max parameter difference less than 0.0001, and illustrate robustness and scalability across a variety of architectures, datasets, and training procedures.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the problem of precisely reconstructing all internal parameters of a neural network with only query access. Specifically, the researchers focus on how to infer the exact weights of a black-box neural network through input-output pairs, which is an NP-hard problem, and existing algorithms have limited effectiveness in practical applications. The paper proposes a new method that can efficiently reconstruct neural networks with over 1.5 million parameters and demonstrates its robustness and scalability across different architectures, datasets, and training processes. ### Main Contributions of the Paper: 1. **Proposed a new sampling method**: Committee Disagreement Sampling, to generate the most informative samples, thereby efficiently unraveling nonlinear relationships. 2. **Theoretical Motivation**: Based on the fact that neural networks are typically trained through random initialization and gradient descent, significantly reducing the actual parameter space. 3. **Experimental Validation**: Successfully reconstructed neural networks with over 1.5 million parameters and demonstrated effectiveness across different activation functions, network architectures, and training datasets. 4. **Performance Comparison**: Outperformed existing best methods in terms of sample efficiency and maximum error. ### Key Challenges Addressed: 1. **Huge Parameter Search Space**: By leveraging the inductive bias during the actual training process of neural networks, significantly reduced the parameter space that needs to be explored. 2. **Selecting the Most Informative Queries**: Proposed the Committee Disagreement Sampling method to generate the most informative samples, improving reconstruction efficiency. ### Significance and Impact: - **Security**: Understanding network structures is crucial for adversarial machine learning and can be used for attacks or defenses. - **Privacy**: Knowing the network weights can infer the training data, which may constitute a serious privacy breach. - **Interpretability**: Reconstructing network weights helps understand the training process and internal mechanisms of the network, reducing the "black-box" effect. - **Security**: Users can ensure the security and reliability of third-party provided networks by reconstructing network weights. - **Biological Considerations**: Reverse engineering artificial neural networks may provide clues for understanding biological neural networks, despite significant differences between the two. ### Limitations and Future Directions: - **Randomness**: Due to the random nature of the method, it sometimes fails, especially when dealing with narrow and deep networks. - **Further Research**: Further research is needed to understand the reasons and conditions for method failure, particularly in narrow and deep networks. - **Future Outlook**: Researchers believe that as network scale increases, their method will become more effective because the weights of large-scale networks change less during training, aligning with their proposed hypothesis. Overall, this paper makes significant progress in the field of precise neural network parameter reconstruction, laying the foundation for future related research.

Sequencing the Neurome: Towards Scalable Exact Parameter Reconstruction of Black-Box Neural Networks

Reconstructing Neural Parameters and Synapses of arbitrary interconnected Neurons from their Simulated Spiking Activity

Optimization Algorithms in Reconstructions of Neuron Morphology: an Overview

Back-engineering of spiking neural networks parameters

Deep Learning-Based Parameter Estimation for Neurophysiological Models of Neuroimaging Data

Hierarchical Parameter Estimation of GRN Based on Topological Analysis

Function-space Parameterization of Neural Networks for Sequential Learning

A Robust Evolutionary Optimisation Approach For Parameterising A Neural Mass Model

Reconstruction of recurrent synaptic connectivity of thousands of neurons from simulated spiking activity

Parametrized constant-depth quantum neuron

Gossamer: Scaling Image Processing and Reconstruction to Whole Brains

Neural Reconstruction Integrity: A metric for assessing the connectivity of reconstructed neural networks

Enhancing Accuracy and Parameter-Efficiency of Neural Representations for Network Parameterization

Efficient Reconstruction of Neural Mass Dynamics Modeled by Linear-Threshold Networks

Polynomial Time Cryptanalytic Extraction of Neural Network Models

BigNeuron: A Resource to Benchmark and Predict Best-Performing Algorithms for Automated Reconstruction of Neuronal Morphology

Network reconstruction via the minimum description length principle

Towards black-box parameter estimation

A Self-Organizing State-Space-Model Approach for Parameter Estimation in Hodgkin-Huxley-Type Models of Single Neurons

Methods and considerations for estimating parameters in biophysically detailed neural models with simulation based inference

The Empirical Impact of Neural Parameter Symmetries, or Lack Thereof