Drawing the boundaries between Blockchain and Blockchain-like systems: A Comprehensive Survey on Distributed Ledger Technologies

Badr Bellaj,Aafaf Ouaddah,Noel Crespi,Abdelatif Mezrioui,Emmanuel Bertin

2024-09-26

Abstract:Bitcoin's global success has led to the rise of blockchain, but many systems labeled as "blockchain" deviate from its core principles, adding complexity to the ecosystem. This survey addresses the need for a comprehensive review and taxonomy to clarify the differences between blockchain and blockchain-like systems. We propose a reference model with four key layers: data, consensus, execution, and application, and introduce a new taxonomy for better classification. Through a qualitative and quantitative analysis of 44 DLT solutions and 26 consensus mechanisms, we highlight key challenges and offer research directions in the field.

Cryptography and Security,Distributed, Parallel, and Cluster Computing

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to solve several key problems in the fields of blockchain technology and distributed ledger technology (DLT):

1. **Confusion in terms and classification**:
- The rapid development of blockchain technology has led to many systems being mislabeled as "blockchain", but in fact they may deviate from the core principles of blockchain. This phenomenon has caused terminological confusion, such as the terms "blockchain", "DLT", or "distributed database" being misunderstood, misused, and misinterpreted.
- Many projects and enterprises use "blockchain" as a pure marketing term, further complicating the understanding of this field.

2. **Lack of standardized definitions**:
- Although there are some standardization proposals (such as ITU, ISO, IEEE), there is currently no widely recognized standardized definition of blockchain or DLT. This has led to different opinions on whether a system meets the blockchain standard.
- The lack of standardization also affects privacy, security, governance, especially interoperability.

3. **Lack of interoperability and integration**:
- There is a lack of interoperability in the DLT ecosystem because the community, under intense competition and commercial pressure, focuses more on launching new systems to improve performance while ignoring system compatibility.
- The lack of a unified technical reference model makes it difficult to evaluate and compare these systems.

4. **Challenges in legal and policy - making**:
- The lack of clear definitions and classifications makes it difficult to formulate and apply DLT - related laws and regulations consistently. For example, confusion may occur in the application of consumer protection laws.
- Precise academic research is affected, hindering the development of innovative applications and solutions.

5. **Complexity of design and adoption decisions**:
- For DLT designers, decision - makers, and project managers, there are significant challenges and trade - offs when designing or adopting DLT solutions, especially when choosing appropriate design options.

### Main objectives of the paper

To address the above problems, the paper proposes the following objectives:

- **Establish clear boundaries**: By presenting a comprehensive literature review and topic taxonomy, clearly distinguish between blockchain and blockchain - like systems.
- **Propose a comprehensive reference model**: Introduce a layered framework that views all DLTs as consisting of four main layers: data layer, consensus layer, execution layer, and application layer.
- **Develop a new taxonomy**: Propose a new taxonomy to enhance the classification of blockchain and blockchain - like systems, providing a more useful perspective than existing work.
- **Conduct a status - quo assessment**: Conduct a comprehensive qualitative and quantitative comparative analysis of 44 DLT solutions and 26 consensus mechanisms from a layered perspective.
- **Highlight design challenges and trade - offs**: Discuss the major challenges and trade - offs faced by DLT designers, decision - makers, and project managers when designing or adopting DLT solutions.
- **Outline research challenges and directions**: Point out the key research challenges and future research directions in the DLT field.

Through these measures, the paper hopes to provide a structured framework for the blockchain and DLT fields, helping researchers and practitioners better understand and compare different DLT technologies and promoting the standardization and wide application of this field.