Adversarial Challenges in Network Intrusion Detection Systems: Research Insights and Future Prospects

Sabrine Ennaji,Fabio De Gaspari,Dorjan Hitaj,Alicia Kbidi,Luigi V. Mancini

2024-10-22

Abstract:Machine learning has brought significant advances in cybersecurity, particularly in the development of Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS). These improvements are mainly attributed to the ability of machine learning algorithms to identify complex relationships between features and effectively generalize to unseen data. Deep neural networks, in particular, contributed to this progress by enabling the analysis of large amounts of training data, significantly enhancing detection performance. However, machine learning models remain vulnerable to adversarial attacks, where carefully crafted input data can mislead the model into making incorrect predictions. While adversarial threats in unstructured data, such as images and text, have been extensively studied, their impact on structured data like network traffic is less explored. This survey aims to address this gap by providing a comprehensive review of machine learning-based Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDS) and thoroughly analyzing their susceptibility to adversarial attacks. We critically examine existing research in NIDS, highlighting key trends, strengths, and limitations, while identifying areas that require further exploration. Additionally, we discuss emerging challenges in the field and offer insights for the development of more robust and resilient NIDS. In summary, this paper enhances the understanding of adversarial attacks and defenses in NIDS and guide future research in improving the robustness of machine learning models in cybersecurity applications.

Cryptography and Security,Emerging Technologies,Networking and Internet Architecture

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is the vulnerability of Network Intrusion Detection Systems (NIDS) when faced with adversarial attacks. Despite significant advancements in improving NIDS performance through machine learning (especially deep learning), these models remain susceptible to adversarial attacks. Adversarial attacks mislead models by carefully crafting input data, causing them to make incorrect predictions. While adversarial threats against unstructured data (such as images and text) have been extensively studied, their impact on structured data (such as network traffic) has not been fully explored.

Specifically, the paper aims to:
1. **Raise Awareness**: Current research on ML-NIDS rarely incorporates adversarial attacks into threat models. These attacks are often overlooked due to feature constraints and interdependencies in structured data. Additionally, adaptive attacks against detection techniques have not been adequately addressed in NIDS research. Given this potential risk, the paper aims to raise awareness within the NIDS community about these attacks.
2. **Provide a Clear Reference Point**: There is currently a lack of comprehensive surveys on the impact of adversarial attacks on NIDS. The paper aims to fill this gap by providing a thorough reference point that covers all aspects of robust network intrusion detection.
3. **Establish Best Practices**: Existing ML-NIDS research uses different datasets, evaluation metrics, and settings, making it difficult to compare study results and identify the strengths and weaknesses of solutions. The paper proposes a set of guidelines and best practices, emphasizing the importance of testing adaptive attacks.

Through these efforts, the paper hopes to enhance the understanding of adversarial attacks and their defense mechanisms, providing guidance for future research.