Abstract:Recent advances in computing power devoted to Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) have opened up a new avenue for addressing the turbulence closure problem through Machine Learning (ML). Several Tensor Basis Neural Network (TBNN) frameworks aimed at enhancing turbulence Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) modeling have recently been proposed in the literature as data-driven constitutive models for systems with known invariance properties. However, persistent ambiguities remain regarding the physical adequacy of applying the General Eddy Viscosity Model (GEVM) within these frameworks. This work aims at investigating this aspect in an a priori stage for better predictions of the Reynolds stress anisotropy tensor, while preserving the Galilean and rotational invariances. In particular, we propose a general framework providing optimal tensor basis models for two types of canonical flows with increasing complexity: Plane Channel Flow (PCF) and Square Duct Flow (SDF). Subsequently, deep neural networks based on these optimal models are trained using state-of-the-art strategies to achieve a balanced and physically sound prediction of the full anisotropy tensor. A priori results obtained by the proposed framework are in very good agreement with the reference Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) data. Notably, our shallow network with three layers excels in providing accurate predictions of the anisotropy tensor for PCF at unobserved friction Reynolds numbers, both in interpolation and extrapolation scenarios. The learning of the SDF case is more challenging because of its physical nature but also due to a lack of training data at various regimes. We propose a numerical strategy to alleviate this problem based on Transfer Learning (TL). In order to more efficiently generalize to an unseen intermediate Reτ regime, we take advantage of our prior knowledge acquired from a training with a larger and wider dataset. Our results indicate the potential of the developed network model, and demonstrate the feasibility and efficiency of the TL process in terms of training data size and training time. Based on these results, we believe there is a promising future by integrating these neural networks into an adapted in-house RANS solver.

Improving the Vector Basis Neural Network for RANS Equations Using Separate Trainings

Practical Framework for Data-Driven RANS Modeling with Data Augmentation

Revisiting Tensor Basis Neural Networks for Reynolds stress modeling: application to plane channel and square duct flows

Physics-Informed Tensor Basis Neural Network for Turbulence Closure Modeling

Revisiting Tensor Basis Neural Network for Reynolds stress modeling: Application to plane channel and square duct flows

Reynolds averaged turbulence modelling using deep neural networks with embedded invariance

Ensemble Kalman method for learning turbulence models from indirect observation data

Improving accuracy of turbulence models by neural network

Neural network models for the anisotropic Reynolds stress tensor in turbulent channel flow

Data-driven RANS closures for improving mean field calculation of separated flows

A data‐driven turbulence modeling for the Reynolds stress tensor transport equation

On the emergence of the Navier-Stokes-$\alpha$ model for turbulent channel flows

Physical interpretation of neural network-based nonlinear eddy viscosity models

Turbulence Modeling for Physics-Informed Neural Networks: Comparison of Different RANS Models for the Backward-Facing Step Flow

A highly accurate strategy for data-driven turbulence modeling

A unified method of data assimilation and turbulence modeling for separated flows at high Reynolds numbers

Are random forests better suited than neural networks to augment RANS turbulence models?

Data Augmented Prediction of Reynolds Stresses for Flows Around an Axisymmetric Body of Revolution

Data-driven approach for modeling Reynolds stress tensor with invariance preservation