Eigenvalue based taste breaking of staggered, Karsten-Wilczek and Borici-Creutz fermions with stout smearing in the Schwinger model

Maximilian Ammer,Stephan Durr

2024-09-23

Abstract:In two spacetime dimensions staggered fermions are minimally doubled, like Karsten-Wilczek and Borici-Creutz fermions. A continuum eigenvalue is thus represented by a pair of near-degenerate eigenvalues, with the splitting $\delta$ quantifying the cut-off induced taste symmetry breaking. We use the quenched Schwinger model to determine the low-lying fermionic eigenvalues (with 0, 1 or 3 steps of stout smearing), and analyze them in view of the global topological charge $q\in\mathbb{Z}$ of the gauge background. For taste splittings pertinent to would-be zero modes, we find asymptotic Symanzik scaling of the form $\delta_\mathrm{wzm} \propto a^2$ with link smearing, and $\delta_\mathrm{wzm} \propto a$ without, for each action. For taste splittings pertinent to non-topological modes, staggered splittings scale as $\delta_\mathrm{ntm} \propto a^p$ (where $p\simeq2$ with smearing and $p=1$ without), while Karsten-Wilczek and Boriçi-Creutz fermions scale as $\delta_\mathrm{ntm} \propto a$ (regardless of the smearing level). Large logarithmic corrections are seen with smearing.

High Energy Physics - Lattice

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to evaluate the degree to which the eigenvalues of the continuous Dirac operator in two - dimensional spacetime (2D) split into a pair of nearly degenerate eigenvalues when using staggered, Karsten - Wilczek (KW) and Boriçi - Creutz (BC) fermions. Specifically, the research focuses on how these splits change with the lattice spacing \(a\), and explores the performance differences of different fermion discretization schemes in dealing with taste symmetry breaking.

### Main Research Contents

1. **Background and Motivation**:
- In four - dimensional spacetime (4D), staggered fermions exhibit taste symmetry breaking, which leads to minimally doubled. To alleviate this effect, researchers try to improve the staggered action by adding evanescent terms or using effective field theory descriptions.
- In two - dimensional spacetime (2D), staggered, Karsten - Wilczek and Boriçi - Creutz fermions are all minimally doubled, which provides an ideal platform for comparing different discretization schemes.

2. **Research Methods**:
- Use the quenched Schwinger model (i.e., compact U(1) gauge theory) for numerical simulation to determine the low - lying eigenvalues.
- Study the impact of taste symmetry breaking by analyzing the eigenvalue splitting corresponding to the global topological charge \(q\in\mathbb{Z}\).
- Explore the influence of different smearing steps (0, 1, 3 steps) on the results.

3. **Main Findings**:
- For non - topological modes, staggered fermions show smaller taste splitting than the other two fermions in the presence of smearing, and their splitting decreases as \(a^{2}\) with the lattice spacing \(a\).
- For would - be zero modes, Karsten - Wilczek fermions show the smallest splitting at all explored lattice spacings and smearing levels.
- The smearing operation seems to change the asymptotic Symanzik scaling behavior of staggered fermions from \(a\) without smearing to \(a^{2}\) with smearing. This phenomenon challenges the standard view that a fixed - level smearing does not change the Symanzik universality class of a given fermion operator.

### Conclusions and Prospects

The authors point out that their findings are unexpected and need further verification. In particular, the change in the asymptotic scaling behavior of staggered fermions may be due to the interaction between smearing and sub - derivative effects. Future research can consider introducing marginal counterterms to further understand these phenomena.

### Formula Summary

- **Smearing Operation**: \[ U_{\text{new}} = U_{\text{old}} + \rho\sum_{\mu}(U_{\mu}(x)+U_{\mu}^{\dagger}(x + \hat{\mu})) \]
- **Geometric Topological Charge**: \[ q_{\text{geo}}^{(n)}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\sum_{x}\Im\log U_{\Box}^{(n)}(x) \]
- **Raw Topological Charge**: \[ q_{\text{raw}}^{(n)}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\sum_{x}\sin[\phi_{1}^{(n)}(x)+\phi_{2}^{(n)}(x+\hat{1})-\phi_{1}^{(n)}(x+\hat{2})-\phi_{2}^{(n)}(x)] \]
- **Asymptotic Symanzik Scaling**: \[ \delta\propto a^{p} \]

Hopefully, this summary can help you better understand the core content and main findings of this paper. If you have any further questions or need more detailed explanations, please feel free to let me know!