Elastic Shape Analysis of Movement Data

J.E. Borgert,Jan Hannig,J.D. Tucker,Liubov Arbeeva,Ashley N. Buck,Yvonne M. Golightly,Stephen P. Messier,Amanda E. Nelson,J.S. Marron
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2409.13938
2024-09-21
Abstract:Osteoarthritis (OA) is a prevalent degenerative joint disease, with the knee being the most commonly affected joint. Modern studies of knee joint injury and OA often measure biomechanical variables, particularly forces exerted during walking. However, the relationship among gait patterns, clinical profiles, and OA disease remains poorly understood. These biomechanical forces are typically represented as curves over time, but until recently, studies have relied on discrete values (or landmarks) to summarize these curves. This work aims to demonstrate the added value of analyzing full movement curves over conventional discrete summaries. Using data from the Intensive Diet and Exercise for Arthritis (IDEA) study (Messier et al., 2009, 2013), we developed a shape-based representation of variation in the full biomechanical curves. Compared to conventional discrete summaries, our approach yields more powerful predictors of disease progression and relevant clinical traits, as demonstrated by a nested model comparison. Notably, our work is among the first to use movement curves to predict disease progression and to quantitatively evaluate the added value of analyzing full movement curves over conventional discrete summaries
Applications
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the added value of full - motion - curve analysis compared to traditional discrete summaries in predicting the progression of knee osteoarthritis (OA) disease and related clinical features. Specifically, the study aims to show whether analyzing complete motion - curve data can provide more powerful predictors of disease progression than traditional discrete summaries. ### Problem Background Knee osteoarthritis (OA) is a common degenerative joint disease that mainly affects the knee joint, manifested as cartilage loss, bone and soft - tissue changes, joint pain, and decreased function. Modern research on knee injuries and OA usually measures biomechanical variables during walking, especially Ground Reaction Forces (GRF). However, the relationship between gait patterns, clinical features, and OA disease has not been fully understood. Traditional research methods usually rely on discrete values (such as peaks) to summarize these time - varying curves, ignoring the rich information in the complete motion curves. ### Research Objectives The main objective of this paper is to show the advantages of the former in predicting disease progression and related clinical features by comparing complete - motion - curve analysis with traditional discrete summaries. The study used data from the Intensive Diet and Exercise for Arthritis (IDEA) study to develop a shape - based representation method to describe the changes in complete biomechanical curves. The study shows that, compared with traditional discrete summaries, this method can provide more powerful predictors of disease progression and was verified through nested - model comparisons. ### Method Overview 1. **Data Collection**: Obtain GRF data generated by participants during walking from the IDEA study, including ground reaction forces in the vertical direction (vGRF), the anterior - posterior direction (apGRF), and the medial - lateral direction (mlGRF). 2. **Data Processing**: Pre - process the raw data, including steps such as rescaling the time axis and linear interpolation, to ensure that all curves are compared within the same time interval. 3. **Elastic Shape Analysis**: Use the Elastic Shape Analysis (ESA) method to align and analyze the complete motion curves and extract amplitude and phase - change patterns. 4. **Statistical Modeling**: Through nested - model comparisons, evaluate the performance differences between predictors based on complete motion curves and traditional discrete summaries in predicting disease progression. ### Conclusions The study shows that complete - motion - curve analysis can capture more information about gait patterns, thereby providing more powerful predictors. This method not only helps to better understand the relationship between gait patterns and knee OA but also provides new tools and perspectives for future clinical research. ### Formula Explanation - The elastic deformation function (Warping Function) is defined as: \[ \gamma(x): [0,1] \to [0,1] \] where \(\gamma\) is a strictly increasing, invertible, and diffeomorphic function. - The Square Root Velocity Function (SRVF) is defined as: \[ q(t)=\text{sign}(\dot{f}(t))\sqrt{|\dot{f}(t)|} \] For any time deformation \(\gamma\), the SRVF transformation is: \[ (q \circ \gamma)\sqrt{\dot{\gamma}} \] - The optimization problem for calculating the deformation function required to align the curves is: \[ \gamma^*_i = \arg\min_{\gamma \in \Gamma}\| \mu_n - q_i \star \gamma \|^2_2+\lambda R(\gamma) \] where \(R(\gamma)\) is a term that penalizes the second derivative of \(\gamma\), and \(\lambda> 0\) controls the penalty intensity. Through these methods, the study shows the potential of complete - motion - curve analysis in knee OA research, providing new ideas and techniques for future research.