Efficient transmutation of long-lived fission products in a Gamma Factory beam driven advanced nuclear energy system

Hu Baolong,Mieczyslaw Witold Krasny,Wieslaw Placzek,Yun Yuan,Xiaoming Shi,Kaijun Luo,Wen Luo

2024-09-19

Abstract:The Gamma Factory (GF) project aims to generate high-intensity $\gamma$-ray beams of tunable energy and relatively small energy spread. Such beams can be optimized to generate an intense photo-neutron source, capable of driving an advanced nuclear energy system (ANES) for nuclear waste transmutation and supplying electrical power that is necessary for the GF operation mode of the Large Hadron Collider storage ring. In this study, we investigate the feasibility of driving ANES with the GF beam which is optimized to maximize the neutron production rate. The dependence of the ANES thermal power on the distance between the positions of the ANES and the GF $\gamma$-ray source is evaluated. For the $\gamma$-ray beam reaching the intensity of $\sim$$10^{19}$ photons per second, the ANES thermal power could exceed $500\,$MWt. Under the assumption that ANES operates over $20$ years, the transmutation rate could reach $30\%$ for five typical long-lived fission products (LLFPs): $^{79}$Se, $^{99}$Tc, $^{107}$Pd, $^{129}$I, $^{137}$Cs. Our comparative studies show that although the neutron production efficiency of the GF $\gamma$-ray beam (per MW of the beam power) is approximately $14$ times lower than that of the $500\,$MeV proton beam, the overall net ANES power production efficiency for the GF beam driver scheme could be comparable to that of the proton beam driver scheme, while providing additional transmutation capacity, not available for the proton beam driven scheme. It is suggested that the GF-based ANES could provide a viable solution for the efficient transmutation of LLFPs without isotopic separation.

Accelerator Physics,High Energy Physics - Experiment,Nuclear Experiment,Applied Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve the problem of safe handling of long - lived fission products (LLFPs) in nuclear waste. Specifically, the paper explores how to use the high - intensity γ - ray beam generated by the Gamma Factory (GF) to drive the Advanced Nuclear Energy System (ANES) in order to achieve efficient LLFPs transmutation without isotope separation and at the same time provide the necessary power to support the operation mode of GF.

### Main research contents

1. **Background and problems**:
- Nuclear power generation is a strategic choice for future energy supply, but it is followed by the problem of spent fuel (SNF) treatment.
- SNF contains long - lived fission products (LLFPs) with high - radioactivity hazards, such as 79Se, 99Tc, 107Pd, 129I, 137Cs, etc. These substances need to be effectively transmuted to reduce their radioactivity hazards.
- Traditional methods rely on isotope separation, but this is technically and economically infeasible.

2. **Solutions**:
- An ANES scheme based on GF is proposed. The high - intensity γ - ray beam drives the photon - neutron source (PNS), which in turn drives the sub - critical reactor for LLFPs transmutation.
- The GF γ - ray beam can generate a high - flux of neutrons, thus achieving efficient LLFPs transmutation.

3. **Specific objectives**:
- Evaluate the influence of the GF γ - ray beam on the ANES thermal power.
- Calculate the ANES thermal power and LLFPs transmutation rate at different distances.
- Compare the advantages and disadvantages of the GF γ - ray beam and the proton - beam - driven scheme.

### Key conclusions

- **Transmutation rate**: During the 20 - year operation cycle, for five typical LLFPs, namely 79Se, 99Tc, 107Pd, 129I and 137Cs, the transmutation rate can reach 30%.
- **Thermal power**: When the γ - ray beam intensity reaches about 10^19 photons/second, the ANES thermal power can exceed 500 MWt.
- **Efficiency comparison**: Although the neutron production efficiency of the GF γ - ray beam is about 14 times lower than that of the 500 MeV proton beam, since isotope separation is not required, the overall net ANES power production efficiency can be comparable to that of the proton - beam - driven scheme.

### Formula summary

- **ANES thermal power formula**:
\[
P_{t\gamma} = E_f\cdot I_\gamma\cdot P_{\gamma n}\cdot k_{eff}\left(\frac{1}{1 - k_{eff}}\right)\cdot\frac{1}{\bar{v}}\cdot\phi
\]
where:
- \(E_f\) is the fission energy.
- \(I_\gamma\) is the γ - ray beam intensity.
- \(P_{\gamma n}\) is the neutron yield per unit γ - ray beam power.
- \(k_{eff}\) is the effective multiplication factor.
- \(\bar{v}\) is the average fission neutron number.
- \(\phi\) is the neutron worth parameter.

- **Neutron worth parameter**:
\[
\phi=\frac{1-\frac{1}{k_{eff}}}{1-\frac{1}{k_s}}
\]

Through these studies, the paper shows the potential of GF γ - ray beam - driven ANES in handling LLFPs, providing new ideas for the effective management of nuclear waste.